The USAID-funded Deep Vision program aims to identify and characterize potential pandemic viruses by collecting samples and sequencing the genomes, and intends to make the data publicly available.
The open data practice of publicly sharing the genomic sequences of potentially dangerous viruses raises concerns about accessibility and the risk of misuse or accidental release of genetic blueprints.
The Deep Vision program focuses on characterizing viruses and assessing their likelihood of spillover from animals to humans, but balancing the benefits of open access with the potential risks poses challenges for global biosecurity.
The security risks associated with Deep Vision include the proliferation of deadly viruses by enabling malicious actors and the possibility of unintentional release of dangerous viruses during the research process, highlighting the need to reevaluate the program's objectives and funding allocation.
Deep dives
Deep Vision Program: Identifying Potential Pandemic Viruses
The Deep Vision program, funded by USAID, aims to identify and characterize potential pandemic viruses. Virus hunting is a major component of the program, involving the collection of samples from various sources, such as wet markets and bush meat markets, to isolate and sequence viruses. The sequencing cost has significantly reduced, allowing for the collection of a record-breaking number of viruses, estimated to be 10,000-12,000 over five years. Characterization involves testing the viruses to determine their potential to bind to human cells, infect cells, replicate in human tissue, and transmit in animal models. This process helps identify viruses that may have pandemic potential. The program's intention is to make the data publicly available, including sharing the genomic sequences of the viruses on platforms like GenBank and GISAID. As soon as potentially dangerous viruses are identified, they will be shared with the relevant countries and promptly disseminated to policymakers, the private sector, and implementing partners.
Implications of Deep Vision's Approach
By publicly sharing the genomic sequences of potentially dangerous viruses, Deep Vision follows an open data practice. However, this approach raises concerns surrounding the accessibility of the information to anyone with the skills to assemble viruses from the genetic code. While the intention is to enhance preparedness and develop interventions to prevent pandemics, the risk of misuse or accidental release of the genetic blueprints remains. The program's success could potentially reveal the existence of many pandemic-capable viruses, presenting a significant challenge in safeguarding the data and preventing unintended consequences. The prospect of making this information widely available raises debates about the balance between scientific progress and the potential risks associated with open access to dangerous viral genomes.
The Need for Caution in Deep Vision's Findings
Deep Vision's objectives involve characterizing viruses and assessing their likelihood of spillover from animals to humans. While there is the possibility of finding high-risk viruses, the outcome is uncertain and may range from zero to a few dozen viruses with pandemic potential. The cost-intensive process of isolating, culturing, and characterizing viruses is a crucial stage in identifying threats. However, the concern arises when potentially dangerous viruses are made publicly available. The balance between the benefits of open access to information for research and the potential risks of misuse and accidental release poses challenges for maintaining global biosecurity. It is important to continue discussions around responsible data sharing and robust strategies to mitigate risks associated with dangerous pathogen research.
Ethical Considerations and Global Cooperation
The Deep Vision program raises ethical concerns regarding the release of genomic information for potentially dangerous viruses. While open data practices within the scientific community have benefits for research and innovation, they also create challenges in managing dual-use findings. The international community needs to address the ethical, legal, and security implications of sharing such sensitive data to ensure global cooperation and proper risk assessment. Collaboration among scientists, policymakers, and stakeholders is crucial to strike a balance between scientific progress, public health, and biosecurity in a rapidly advancing field.
The Security Risks of Deep Vision: A Critical Analysis
Deep Vision, a proposed program funded by USAID, aims to discover and identify potential pandemic-causing viruses for research and vaccine development. However, there are significant security concerns surrounding this approach. One key issue is the risk of proliferation, as making detailed genomic information of potential pathogens publicly accessible could enable malicious actors to create and release deadly viruses. This would exponentially increase the number of individuals capable of inflicting a large-scale pandemic. Another concern is the potential for unintentional release of dangerous viruses during the research process. Furthermore, the focus on identifying pandemic-capable viruses may overshadow other important aspects such as effective response measures and broad-spectrum vaccine development. The argument that deep vision could aid in the development of panfamilial vaccines is countered by the fact that knowing the specific genome of each potential virus is unnecessary for such development. It is also important to consider the international implications of deep vision, as other countries could potentially conduct similar research without the same level of scrutiny. Therefore, it is crucial to reevaluate the objectives and funding allocation of deep vision to minimize security risks and prioritize effective pandemic prevention efforts.
Potential Actions to Influence Deep Vision
For those concerned about the security risks associated with deep vision, there are various ways to express your concerns and potentially influence the program. One approach is to voice your thoughts on social media platforms, such as Twitter, by tagging the official USAID account (@USAID) and expressing the need to reconsider the research objectives. Another option is to visit the USAID website and use their contact form or phone number to directly communicate your concerns. Additionally, reaching out to your elected representatives, particularly if they serve on the Senate Foreign Relations Subcommittee on State Department and USAID Management, can be an effective way to raise awareness and influence decision-making. It is crucial to convey the potential security risks involved and advocate for the redirection of funds towards alternative pandemic prevention strategies.
Opportune Time for Action
Although deep vision has been approved, it has not yet been launched, creating a window of opportunity to address the security concerns surrounding the program. It is essential to act swiftly as soon as possible before substantial progress is made with potential security implications. This critical moment presents a chance to reevaluate the funding and objectives of deep vision and potentially redirect resources towards more effective pandemic prevention measures. By raising awareness and engaging with relevant stakeholders, there is a strong possibility of influencing the direction of the program and mitigating potential security risks.
Evaluation of Deep Vision's Precedent and Potential Impact
Deep Vision carries reputational risks and potential security implications that must be rigorously addressed. While its initial goal of virus discovery is reasonable, the subsequent step of characterizing and identifying pandemic-capable viruses raises the most significant concerns. The program's focus should shift towards prevention efforts, effective response measures, and broad-spectrum vaccine development rather than concentrating solely on identifying potential pathogens. By demonstrating a commitment to halting virus enhancement research and rallying international support against the proliferation of pandemic-capable viruses, a more responsible and secure framework can be established. This requires close collaboration among different organizations, reassessment of programs such as deep vision, and a wider recognition of the need to prioritize global security and pandemic prevention.
USAID’s new “DEEP VZN” program aims to discover new pandemic-grade viruses, then broadcast their genomes to the world, according to MIT evolutionary engineer Kevin Esvelt. He estimates that 30,000 people in dozens of countries could then easily assemble them.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
