“Elite” Functional Fitness | Starting Strength Radio #226
Aug 18, 2023
auto_awesome
Dr. Joel Seedman, expert in athletic training and rehabilitation, joins the show to discuss the uselessness of current functional fitness trends. They delve into dangerous ACL rehab, low resistance workouts, and the importance of training like the sport. They also critique water aerobics for athletes and debunk the misconception that adding bands improves performance.
Functional training often fails to provide the necessary stress for physiological adaptation, and emphasis on balance-oriented movements disregards the importance of strength production.
Many trainers lack the knowledge to effectively coach athletes, and misguided practices like ACL re-injury programs put athletes at risk of further harm.
The media's portrayal of visually impressive exercises as effective training methods creates a misconception about the importance of strength training for athletes.
Deep dives
Misguided Fitness Trends: Functional Training vs. Strength Training
Functional training is often promoted by the media as the go-to fitness approach, but it often misses the mark. While visually impressive, functional training fails to provide the necessary stress for physiological adaptation. It focuses on inventing new ways to make exercises look dynamic and balance-oriented, rather than emphasizing strength production. The videos showcased in this episode feature talented athletes who are already genetically gifted and naturally athletic. The activities they demonstrate only serve to display their existing abilities, not to further develop them. In contrast, true strength training involves planned and recorded sessions that progressively increase difficulty to drive physical adaptation. It's essential to recognize the disconnect between media-promoted fitness trends and the principles of effective strength training.
The Pitfalls of Inadequate Coaching and ACL Re-Injury Programs
Many trainers in the fitness industry lack the knowledge to effectively coach athletes, especially at the professional level. They focus on flashy exercises that make performances look impressive. However, these exercises often fall short in providing the necessary stress for proper physiological adaptation. One example is the ACL re-injury programs, which expose the repaired ligament to instability instead of protecting and strengthening it. These misguided practices put athletes at risk of further injury. It's essential to recognize that athletes require proper training and practice, not performative workouts, to enhance their skills in their respective sports.
The Disconnect Between Media Portrayals and Actual Training
The media plays a significant role in shaping public perception of fitness and athletic training. They often focus on visually impressive exercises and activities, presenting them as effective training methods. However, these portrayals fail to convey the true importance of strength training for athletes. They promote functional training approaches that prioritize balance-oriented movements over strength production. This disconnect between media-promoted fitness trends and actual training principles can lead to misconceptions and confusion. It's crucial to understand the difference between visually impressive workouts and the necessary stress required for physiological adaptation in effective training.
The Importance of Strength Training for Athletic Performance
Strength training is essential for improving athletic performance, whether you are an elite NFL player or a regular person engaging in physical activities. The belief that functional training or specialized exercises are more effective is misguided. The best way to improve performance is by getting stronger, which is the low-hanging fruit that often goes untapped. Regardless of the level of play, the basic needs for athletic development are the same: to improve strength. Strength is the foundation that enhances balance, injury resistance, and overall athletic ability. This can be achieved by focusing on compound exercises like squats, deadlifts, presses, and chin-ups with full range of motion and progressively increasing the weight over time.
The Ineffectiveness of Functional Training
Functional training, often promoted as a way to enhance athletic performance, is criticized for its lack of efficacy. Exercises such as using stability balls, bands, or doing dancing-like movements fail to provide the necessary stress to stimulate adaptation and improve performance. These activities mainly serve as a display, impressing coaches and officials while offering little to no athletic development. Instead of focusing on such distractions, the key is to prioritize strength training, which has a direct and significant impact on increasing power and speed in athletes. By challenging athletes through proper squatting, deadlifting, pressing, and other compound exercises performed with heavier weights, athletes can develop superior explosiveness and economy of movement, making them stronger, faster, and better equipped for their respective sports.
Rip gets exposed to videos of professional and Division 1 strength and conditioning methods and the crew discuss why the current functional fitness trend is useless.
02:12 Comments from the Haters!
09:56 Intro to functional fitness
17:49 Ideas from the media
25:06 What IS being done on the pro level
37:35 Wasted potential
45:08 Dr. Joel Seedman
48:32 Dangerous ACL rehab
51:41 Flash Garrett’s low resistance
53:27 Christian McCaffrey displays athleticism
54:36 Making training like the sport
1:01:13 Playing games instead of training
1:03:36 Practicing incorrectly
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode