Join Mike Keen, an adventurous chef and Arctic explorer, as he unravels the mysteries of weight management through diet and exercise. Alongside Chris Van Tulleken, a medical doctor and author focusing on processed foods, Nigel Smith, a sports dietitian, and Andrew Jenkinson, an obesity surgeon, they delve into the surprising relationship between physical activity and weight loss. Discover how traditional diets, exercise misconceptions, and the concept of weight set points all play critical roles in our health and fitness journeys.
Mike Keen's weight fluctuations during his expeditions highlight the complex relationship between exercise, diet quality, and body weight regulation.
Experts indicate that dietary management is more crucial than exercise for weight loss, emphasizing the hormonal effects of processed foods.
Deep dives
Extreme Diet and Weight Loss Observations
An explorer named Mike Keene undertook an expedition in Greenland where he kayaked extensively while consuming a traditional Inuit diet, primarily consisting of protein and fat from marine sources. During the first trip, he lost 14 kilos while engaging in intense physical activity, likening it to running a half marathon daily in harsh conditions. Surprisingly, after returning to the UK, his weight rebounded to 90 kilos, sparking questions about the mechanisms of weight loss and maintenance. The experience prompted an exploration of how extreme diets combined with physical exertion affect body composition and energy expenditure in both active and inactive states.
Impact of Exercise on Weight Management
Experts debated the common belief that exercise significantly contributes to weight loss, revealing that for most individuals, the calories burned through typical exercise do not sufficiently compensate for dietary intake. Research indicates that daily energy expenditure remains similar across varied lifestyles, meaning even the most physically active individuals like the Hadza tribe do not burn more calories than sedentary populations. The experts concluded that while exercise is beneficial for overall health, it is not as effective as dietary management in addressing weight gain. This shifts the focus towards the quality of food consumed as a critical factor influencing obesity and metabolism.
The Weight Set Point Theory
The discussion introduced the concept of a 'weight set point', which describes the body's inherent tendency to maintain a certain weight influenced by genetics and dietary environments. This mechanism can explain why individuals regain weight after temporary loss, as the body seeks to restore its set point, often resulting in intense cravings and metabolic slows during calorie restriction. Mike's observations of fluctuating weight between Greenland and the UK illustrated how different food environments could shift his set point, reinforcing the idea that hormonal signals related to diet heavily impact weight management. The role of insulin in elevating hunger levels within this framework emphasizes the need for awareness regarding processed foods and sugar intake.
Integrating Findings for Future Research
Mike's experiences and the insights of the experts have influenced his perspective on the pursuit of a healthier diet and lifestyle, particularly regarding indigenous food sources. The importance of ancestral diets and traditional cooking studied during his travels highlights the need to connect with historical dietary practices that have been lost in modern society. Additionally, understanding that processed foods can disrupt regulatory hormones like leptin and insulin positions food quality as a crucial component in addressing obesity. Mike aims to explore this integration further in future expeditions, focusing on indigenous diets before their potential disappearance.
Want to lose weight? How much can you achieve through exercise? Dan Saladino investigates with the help of Mike Keen, a chef and Arctic explorer.
Mike has had numerous adventures in Greenland, including kayaking thousands of miles, and sometimes doing nothing at all. What happened to his weight on this trips has left him puzzled.
They enlist the help three experts, Chris Van Tulleken, author of Ultra Processed People; Nigel Smith of the UK Sports Institute and Andrew Jenkinson, surgeon and author of Why We Eat too Much and How to Eat.
Produced and presented by Dan Saladino.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode