The Counsel of Trent

#646 - The Assumption of Mary: Protestant Critique (REBUTTED)

Aug 16, 2022

01:36:41

Creator website

Episode guests

Gavin Ortlund

Highlights

AI Chapters

Episode notes

Argument from Silence Against the Assumption

01:20

All Christians agree there are non-Gospel essential beliefs

01:20

Why Don't More Fathers Talk About It?

01:05

Whether or not she died?

00:52

Introduction

2min

The Doctrine of the Assumption of the Exodus by Dr Ortland

4min

Is There Any Dogma of the Virgin Birth?

4min

The Role of Mary in the Catholic Church

2min

The Bodily Assumption and Mareology

2min

Mary Should Be Held in High Esteem

2min

Is There Any Reason on Earth to Think That God Exists?

3min

The Bodily Assumption

3min

The History of Catholicism - Is There Any Historical Evidence for It?

4min

10.

The Dormisian Narrative of Mary's Dormission

4min

11.

The Origins of the Dormitian Traditions

3min

12.

The Bodily Assumption of Mary

3min

13.

Why the 400+ Years of Total Silence?

4min

14.

The Early Dating of Mary's Repose

2min

15.

Why Nobody's Talking About the Assumption of Mary for 400 Years

1min

16.

Is There an Oral Tradition That Says Mary Was Assumed to Heaven?

5min

17.

The Garden of Paradise

2min

18.

I Don't See How Isidore Is Aware of Specific Oral Tradition Related to Mary's Death

4min

19.

Is There a Lack of Discussion of Mary's End?

4min

20.

The Silence of the Fathers and Ecclesia Writers

5min

21.

Shoemaker: Is There an Oral Tradition of Mary's Assumption?

5min

22.

How Do We Account for the Astonishing Diversity of the Stories of Mary's Assumption?

3min

23.

Is There a Bodily Assumption?

3min

24.

The Historical Origin of Mary's Death and Her Assumption

4min

25.

The Book of Mary's Repose Is a Gnostic Narrative

2min

26.

Do We Have Good Grounds for Denying a Doctrine?

5min

27.

Is the Woman in Revelation 12 a Sign, Not a Literal Mother?

3min

28.

Whether Revelation Is a Christian Document or Not?

4min

29.

Is There a Bodily Assumption of Mary?

4min

30.

The Infallible Dogma of Mary's Assumption

3min

In this rebuttal video Trent examines Gavin Ortlund’s case against belief in the Blessed Virgin Mary’s Bodily Assumption into heaven.

Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts

Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.