The Lawfare Podcast

Richard Gowan on the U.S. Push for UN Security Council Reform

Jun 22, 2023
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Ukraine War Reignited Council Reform

  • Russia's invasion of Ukraine revitalized long-dormant Security Council reform discussions by exposing the Council's inability to check a veto-wielding P5 member.
  • President Biden publicly backing reform in September 2022 turned diplomatic chatter into a credible US-led push in New York.
INSIGHT

US Plan Likely Adds Non-Veto Permanent Seats

  • The likely US approach is to add roughly six new permanent seats (G4 plus two African seats) and expand elected seats, moving the Council toward ~25 members.
  • This preserves the P5 vetoes while creating a middle tier of permanent members without veto power.
INSIGHT

Non-Veto Seats Offer Influence But Not Full Power

  • New permanent membership without vetoes gives status and consistent influence but not veto power; some aspirants (India) may find that insufficient.
  • Germany and Japan might accept non-veto permanency; India likely insists on a veto to match its ambitions.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app