#199: Katelyn Bourgoin – How to write great social content (and lessons learned from her recent launch) [Greatest Hits]
Mar 4, 2025
auto_awesome
Katelyn Bourgoin, founder of Customer Camp and writer of the popular buyer psychology newsletter 'Why We Buy,' shares her expertise in crafting engaging content. She discusses her unique approach to short-form writing, likening it to chocolate-covered almonds—engaging yet substantial. Katelyn highlights the risks of growing social media accounts too large and reflects on lessons learned from her recent cohort launch. She also explores how identifying a 'villain' can deepen brand engagement and the importance of authenticity in building community.
Caitlin Bourgoin emphasizes the importance of engaging content that combines a captivating hook with substantial core information for effective audience connection.
She highlights the psychological aspect of familiarity bias, warning creators that large accounts risk complacency in content quality and engagement.
Reflecting on her recent launch, Caitlin discusses the need for improved pricing communication and pre-sales strategies to enhance enrollment and customer alignment.
Deep dives
Caitlin Burgoyne's Approach to Audience Building
Caitlin Burgoyne emphasizes the importance of effectively building an audience of future buyers through her cohort program, Unignorable. She acknowledges that while measurable success can be seen in the number of students enrolled, around 306 in the latest cohort, there were aspects of the launch that could have been handled better. With a focus on psychological triggers, Caitlin teaches creators how to understand and engage their audience more effectively. She highlights that creating trust and an opportunity for people to learn is a significant achievement in itself, showcasing her commitment to fostering genuine connections.
The Anatomy of Effective Social Media Posts
Caitlin describes her method for creating engaging social media content, likening it to a chocolate-covered almond. She explains that the hook serves as the chocolate, drawing people in, while the core content provides substance. Offering clear strategies for writing compelling posts, Caitlin discusses the necessity of crafting both an enticing beginning and a satisfying conclusion. This dual structure ensures that followers not only engage with her content but also identify with her as a source of valuable insights.
Understanding the Role of Familiarity and Relationships
Caitlin delves into the psychology behind audience engagement, asserting the power of familiarity bias in attracting viewers. She points out that larger accounts can often coast on their known reputation, which can sometimes lead to complacency in content quality. This highlights the challenge for emerging creators who strive to earn attention in an oversaturated market. The discussion encourages content creators to focus on long-lasting relationships with their audience rather than short-term tricks, suggesting that trust and credibility hold more value over time.
Strategies for Course Launch Success
During the discussion, Caitlin reflects on her experience with the recent launch of Unignorable, outlining her thoughts on optimizing course offering strategies. She highlights the significance of pre-sales and effective communication of pricing strategies to create urgency and increase enrollment. Feedback from participants indicated that pricing was a concern, which pointed to a need for better positioning of the program against competitors. Ultimately, Caitlin underscores the importance of refining marketing strategies and delivering value to better align customer expectations.
Navigating Burnout in Audience Building
Caitlin shares her perspective on the potential burnout among content creators focused on audience building, particularly within B2B contexts. She suggests that there could be a waning appetite for audience growth amidst a glut of courses and advice promoting such practices. This insight prompts her to consider how to adapt her content and programs to a potentially fatigued audience. By addressing this dilemma, Caitlin aims to cultivate a more engaged and motivated community, positioning her offerings as relevant and valuable in a changing landscape.
Katelyn Bourgoin is the founder of Customer Camp and the writer behind the buyer psychology newsletter, Why We Buy, which has nearly 75,000 subscribers.
Katelyn is also the co-creator of a couple of great products. The first being Unignorable, a 36 day group challenge designed to help you build an audience of future buyers. That's a collaboration with the Demand Curve team.
And the second is Wallet Opening Words, 26 and a half science-backed copywriting techniques. That's a collaboration with friend of the podcast, Phil Agnew.
So in this episode, you'll learn
Katelyn's approach to short form writing
Why she treats her content like a chocolate covered almond
The risk that comes with accounts getting too big
And what she would do differently the next time she launches her cohort program