168. Daniel Dennett & Gregg Caruso — Just Deserts: Debating Free Will (moderated by Michael Shermer)

1

Introduction

00:00 • 5min

2

Are We Still Debating Free Will?

05:19 • 4min

3

Is Libertarianism a Good Idea?

09:20 • 3min

4

The Problem With Quantum Randomness Isn't Free Will

12:08 • 4min

5

The Pragmatist Approach to the Issue of Prison Reform

16:12 • 2min

6

The Pragmatic Argument for Libertarian Free Will

18:03 • 4min

7

The Varieties of Free Will Worth Wanting

22:22 • 5min

8

Determinism Is Truth, It's Not Indeterminism

27:46 • 3min

9

A Second Cause of Moral Responsibility

30:53 • 2min

10

Is There a Justification for the Desert System?

33:15 • 4min

11

The Right of Coercion and the Limiting of Liberty

37:06 • 2min

12

I'll Quarrantine Myself in Maralago for the Rest of My Life

39:36 • 5min

13

Is There a Difference in Treatment Between Mya and Marina?

44:09 • 5min

14

Wewea to Hang On. Greg, Hangon. Greg.

49:35 • 2min

15

The Death Penalty

51:07 • 2min

16

Don't Let This Guy Out of Jail, but Should He Not Be Punished?

53:30 • 5min

17

The Manipulation Argument

58:44 • 5min

18

How Would Your Model Deal With Degrees of Murder?

01:03:54 • 6min

19

The Only Ground for Incapacitation

01:09:49 • 2min

20

Is Deliberation Consistent With Reason?

01:11:57 • 2min

21

The Issue of Punishment

01:13:41 • 3min

22

Prisoner Punishment

01:17:02 • 3min

23

Is There a Justification for Punishment?

01:20:07 • 3min

24

Is There Any Such Thing as Basic Moral Desert?

01:23:23 • 3min

25

Is There a Real Divide?

01:26:44 • 4min

26

Is Determinism Morally Responsible?

01:30:58 • 4min

27

Is John a Serial Philanderer?

01:34:53 • 4min

28

Moral Responsibility Practices Can Change Over Time

01:39:03 • 2min

29

Is the Law Dependent on Retributive Reactions?

01:41:25 • 3min

30

Retributive Punishment

01:44:00 • 5min

31

The Punishment Should Fit the Crime

01:48:30 • 4min

32

I'm Calling You a Mixed Theorist

01:52:38 • 6min

33

The Punishment Should Fit the Crime

01:58:18 • 2min

34

Do You Really Have to Enforce Those Rules?

01:59:52 • 3min

35

Moral Anger and Blame Are Not Justifiable

02:02:55 • 3min