The Martyr Made Podcast #9 – Sacrifice & Oppression at the Dawn of Tyranny
State Monopoly on Violence
- States use coercion and violence to enforce laws.
- They monopolize legitimate violence, unlike stateless societies where self-help prevails.
Tribal Vendettas vs. State Law
- Modern nation-building struggles to impose state control over tribal societies.
- Local police hesitate to enforce laws, fearing blood feuds, as seen in Afghanistan.
Early Humans and Egalitarianism
- Early humans were likely egalitarian, with social prestige based on sharing.
- This contrasts with modern societies marked by vast inequalities.
“Mexica ‘beliefs’ have been discussed confidently enough, but academics being natural theologians, usually at an unnaturally abstract pitch. My interest is not in belief at this formal level, but in sensibility: the emotional, moral, and aesthetic nexus through which thought comes to be expressed in action, and so made public, visible, and accessible to our observation.”
-Inga Clenninden | Aztecs: An Interpretation
Human sacrifice is not a human universal. The institution emerges at a specific stage of human sociopolitical development, and recedes when the transition is complete. Rarely found among nomadic hunter-gatherers, ritual homicide is also nearly absent in archaic civilizations (except for a few residual instances such as royal burials). But human beings didn’t make the leap from nomadic foragers to pyramid builders overnight. Nestled between was a transitional stage, when newly-settled people faced the monumental task of ditching the ancient kinship system, sacrificing their freedom to kings, and reorganizing themselves into the first states. This fraught transition was imposed by violence, as primitive egalitarianism was replaced by class oppression, and human sacrifice was employed to define social boundaries and to stave off panic with brutal acts of self-assertion. Kings gloried in their total freedom, the less fortunate were terrorized into submission, and the gods looked on with dripping fangs and growling stomachs.
If you would like to donate to help put some kibble in my bowl, you can do it at Patreon, or PayPal (email: martyrmade at gmail.com). Thank you to those of you who have donated, I really don’t know what to say other than that. Thank you.