150. Daniel Lieberman — Exercised: Why Something We Never Evolved to Do is Healthy and Rewarding
Jan 5, 2021
auto_awesome
Daniel Lieberman, a Harvard evolutionary biology professor and author, delves into the paradox that humans did not evolve to exercise but rather for physical activities necessary for survival. He discusses how modern sedentary lifestyles contribute to health issues and why understanding our evolutionary past is crucial. Lieberman also challenges traditional views on sleep and exercise, suggesting optimal sleep is around six to seven hours and advocating for a balanced approach to physical activity. He critiques BMI as a health measure, emphasizing the importance of fat distribution and the need for preventative health through diet and exercise.
Daniel Lieberman argues that humans evolved for necessary physical activities, not intentional exercise, which conflicts with modern workout motivations.
Research shows that contemporary sedentary lifestyles drastically reduce physical activity levels compared to traditional hunter-gatherer societies' daily routines.
Effective health maintenance requires a holistic approach encompassing exercise, diet, genetics, and social connections, rather than relying solely on physical activity.
Deep dives
Podcast Name Change and Scholarly Approach
The transition from the Science Salon podcast to The Michael Shermer Show reflects a growing desire for clarity and accessibility in discussing broad scientific concepts. The original name was often misunderstood, as the term 'salon' does not resonate with many audiences today. Shermer emphasizes that his interpretation of science extends beyond traditional realms, encompassing various disciplines such as history, philosophy, and social issues. This broader approach aims to engage listeners with a wide array of perspectives while advocating for the importance of reason, rationality, and critical thinking.
Role of Exercise in Human Evolution
Dr. Daniel Lieberman's book, 'Exercised,' argues that human beings did not evolve to engage in intentional exercise, making modern workouts somewhat foreign to our natural tendencies. Instead, the inherent physical activity needed for survival was woven into daily tasks, such as hunting and gathering. When asking non-Western groups about their exercise habits, responses often indicate that intentionally running or training for fitness is nonsensical behavior. This highlights a crucial distinction between exercise as a structured activity and physical activity that is organically part of our lives.
Comparative Activity Levels: Hunter-Gatherers vs. Modern Society
Research indicates that hunter-gatherers exhibit significantly higher levels of physical activity compared to modern sedentary populations. Studies have shown that people in these traditional lifestyles walk between five to nine miles daily, often engaging in moderate to vigorous physical tasks. In contrast, many modern individuals struggle to meet recommendations for just 150 minutes of exercise per week. This stark difference illustrates that achieving an active lifestyle may require more conscious effort in contemporary society.
Interconnected Benefits of Different Exercises
Combining various forms of exercise, such as cardio and strength training, offers comprehensive health benefits that target different aspects of physical fitness. Cardiovascular activities improve heart health and overall endurance, while resistance training helps maintain muscle mass and combat age-related declines in strength. The body's response to exercise involves complex mechanisms that enhance metabolic health and reduce risks associated with various diseases, including obesity and diabetes. Daniel Lieberman emphasizes that individuals should find exercises they enjoy to promote sustainable physical activity.
Health Beyond the Scope of Exercise: Holistic Considerations
While exercise is crucial for reducing vulnerability to numerous diseases, it's essential to recognize that it is not a panacea. Factors such as diet, genetics, and social connections also contribute significantly to overall health. For instance, some studies suggest that a healthy marriage and strong social relationships can lower mortality risk more effectively than exercise alone. Empowering oneself through knowledge of diverse health factors can lead to better lifestyle choices, contributing to a higher quality of life both now and as one ages.
Addressing the Inequalities in Access to Physical Activity
The podcast highlights disparities in physical activity opportunities, particularly exacerbated by social inequalities. Individuals from lower socio-economic backgrounds may find it challenging to engage in regular exercise due to time constraints, access to facilities, and environmental factors. The current narrative around health promotion needs to incorporate systemic change to ensure that all individuals have the opportunity to embrace active lifestyles. Creating environments that encourage physical activity for all communities can help mitigate these disparities.
“Nothing about the biology of exercise makes sense except in the light of evolution, and nothing about exercise as a behavior makes sense except in the light of anthropology.”
In this myth-busting book, Daniel Lieberman, professor of human evolutionary biology at Harvard University and a pioneering researcher on the evolution of human physical activity, tells the story of how we never evolved to exercise — to do voluntary physical activity for the sake of health. Using his own research and experiences throughout the world, Lieberman recounts how and why humans evolved to walk, run, dig, and do other necessary and rewarding physical activities while avoiding needless exertion. As our increasingly sedentary lifestyles have contributed to skyrocketing rates of obesity and diseases such as diabetes, Lieberman argues that to become more active we need to do more than medicalize and commodify exercise.
Shermer and Lieberman also discuss:
evolutionary and anthropological perspectives on physical activity,
why we never evolved to exercise,
physical activity vs. exercise,
sleep: how much do we really need?
walking vs. running; speed vs. strength,
endurance and aging: why exercise matters,
why we age and die,
exercise and diet,
Should we do weights, cardio, or high-intensity training?
Is sitting really the new smoking?
Is BMI really a useful measure?
exercise and disease: obesity, diabetes/metabolic syndrome, cardiovascular disease (and cholesterol), osteoporosis, Alzheimer’s, depression, and cancer,
immune systems and exercise, and
How much exercise should you get each week?
Daniel E. Lieberman is Edwin M. Lerner Professor of Biological Sciences and professor of human evolutionary biology at Harvard University. He is the author of the national best seller The Story of the Human Body: Evolution, Health, and Disease. He lives in Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode