Join Jane Christian, Managing Director of Analytics & Insight at EssenceMediacom UK, Rich Kirk, Chief Strategy Officer at EssenceMediacom UK, and Nic Pietersma, Group Director at Ebiquity, as they dive into the latest findings of the 'Profit Ability 2' study. They discuss how recent global challenges have reshaped marketing effectiveness and the importance of rigorous data analysis in assessing advertising ROI. The trio highlights the significance of balancing short-term and long-term strategies while exploring the surprising effectiveness of traditional media channels in driving profitability.
The updated 'Profit Ability 2' study emphasizes the need for advertisers to adjust their expectations regarding the timing of returns on their media investments after significant market changes.
Research findings reveal that while traditional media like linear TV has become less effective, digital platforms may provide better efficiencies, prompting strategies for optimized spending across channels.
Deep dives
The Urgency for Updated Advertising Insights
A renewed urgency for a comprehensive advertising study arose following significant market shifts and challenges posed by the pandemic and rising living costs. The original 'Profitability' study from 2017 had established advertising as a profitable growth driver, but the changing landscape necessitated a fresh perspective. By including a larger array of brands and sector-wide data, the updated study aimed to reflect current realities impacting advertising effectiveness and return on investment (ROI). This extensive re-examination helped address uncertainties in advertising strategy that had grown amidst evolving consumer behavior and market conditions.
Methodological Innovations in Analyzing Advertising Efficacy
The new study employed a more sophisticated methodology by encompassing a diverse range of brands and utilizing marketing mix modeling (MMM) that analyzed immediate and sustained effects of advertising investments. By examining over 141 brands and ten media channels, the research aimed to deepen understanding of how advertising translates into profit rather than merely revenue. Notably, the study distinguished between immediate returns and longer-term benefits, revealing that a significant portion of advertising value is realized well after initial campaigns are launched. This nuanced approach highlighted the need for advertisers to recalibrate their expectations concerning when they will see returns on their media investments.
The Impact of Pandemic on Advertising Effectiveness
The research revealed that the COVID-19 pandemic had lasting implications on advertising effectiveness, notably in the way consumers interact with media. While some anticipated dramatic shifts in ROI metrics, the findings demonstrated that overall returns for advertisers had only slightly declined, indicating a relatively stable landscape despite chaos in media consumption behaviors. However, traditional channels like linear TV experienced a loss in effectiveness, with greater scrutiny on their returns, while digital platforms showcased better efficiencies. Understanding these changes is crucial for brands as they re-align their strategies to optimize media investments post-pandemic.
Spotlight on Media Spending and Effectiveness
The findings underscored discrepancies in media spending versus effectiveness, particularly regarding paid social channels, which often received more investment than warranted based on their ROI. Advertisers showed a tendency to over-allocate budgets to social platforms despite the study suggesting substantial room for improvement in traditional media segments, like linear TV and online video. This misalignment poses critical questions for brands about their spending habits and effectiveness metrics, prompting a reconsideration of how media investments correspond to desired business outcomes. As a result, the study advocates for a reevaluation of marketing strategies to yield optimal returns across various advertising channels.
WARC's Alex Brownsell speaks to EssenceMediacom UK's Jane Christian, Managing Director of Analytics & Insight, and Rich Kirk, Chief Strategy Officer, and Nic Pietersma, Group Director at Ebiquity.
Discussing ‘Profit Ability 2’, the follow-up to a 2017 meta-study that set out the case for advertising as a profitable driver of business growth. Marketing effectiveness wisdom has been challenged by the pandemic, the cost-of-living crisis and significant behavioural shifts – so an up to date, robust view of the role for advertising investment was needed more than ever.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode