School of War

Ep 54: Jonathan Kirshner on Realism

Dec 20, 2022
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Realism Vs. Structural Realism

  • Realism centers on the anarchic international system and states' need for self-help.
  • Classical realism differs from structural realism by emphasizing states' purposes, history, and ideas as drivers of behavior.
INSIGHT

Why Structural Realism Dominated

  • Structural realism rose because scholars wanted parsimonious, science-like theories and Waltz provided a clear framework.
  • Classical realism resists mechanistic natural-science models and stresses uncertainty, motives, and context-specific judgment.
ADVICE

Practice Judgment Over Mechanistic Models

  • Treat world politics like gardening, not mechanics: gather evidence but apply judgment to particular actors and contexts.
  • Prepare for uncertainty rather than pretending you face known probability distributions.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app