Shameless Popery

A probing look at why Christians gather on Sunday instead of Saturday. The Sabbatarian challenge and claims about Constantine's 321 law are examined. Early patristic and apostolic-era evidence is surveyed. The discussion contrasts Sabbath theology with the rise of the Lord's Day and explores whether Sunday worship predates imperial influence.

A reflective look at three takeaways from Rhett McLaughlin’s deconstruction. Discussion of how insisting on nonessential doctrines can burden seekers. Exploration of evolution’s role in shaking trust in evangelical apologetics. Consideration of faith and reason as compatible and how to evaluate miracles and truth claims fairly.

A critical look at claims that Jesus alone can determine which books belong in the Bible. The discussion tests standards like reference, quotation, and invocation and shows how they lead to contradictions. It examines sectional arguments about Jewish canon boundaries and argues that Scripture by itself cannot settle the canon.

Explore the intriguing concept of the 'Counterfeit Argument' and how it misleads religious debates. Joe breaks down various claims against Catholicism, like the authority of councils and the nature of papal legitimacy. He tackles myths surrounding the Western Schism and the biblical canon, shedding light on historic misconceptions. Plus, discover how the notion of multiple gods fails to dispel the idea of one true God. Fascinating insights into unity and the church's purpose round out this compelling discussion.

In this discussion, Joe tackles a common Protestant objection about the Eucharist, challenging the idea that St. Paul's use of 'bread' means it’s only symbolic. He explores John 6 to reveal Christ's true presence in the Eucharist. Through Greek distinctions and insights from the Gospels, he illustrates how the notion of ‘one loaf’ connects believers to Christ. Early Church Fathers are referenced to show the consistent belief in the real presence of Jesus in the bread, highlighting the Eucharist's role in unifying the Church.

In this discussion, the critique of the Catholic priesthood is tackled head-on. Joe emphasizes that Jesus' role as the unique mediator doesn’t exclude human ministers in reconciliation. He explores mediation, confession, and the scriptural basis for a distinct priesthood. Citing biblical texts, he argues that the authority to forgive and the concept of a royal priesthood align with Catholic teaching. Joe also highlights the significance of the Eucharist as a true sacrifice, connecting it to early Christian writings and tradition.

Dive into the intriguing question of why Jesus, being sinless, chose to be baptized. The discussion tackles the apparent contradiction head-on, debunking myths around repentance and imputed sin. Joe explores the true purpose of this act—submission, the start of Jesus' public ministry, and solidarity with sinners. He also highlights how this moment sanctifies baptism for future believers. It's a fascinating exploration of faith, righteousness, and the transformative power of baptism.

A recent debate sparked a compelling discussion on the Great Apostasy. The host argues that the New Testament church was a visible and organized entity. He traces Rome's early reputation as a center of faith and leadership. Key figures like Ignatius and Irenaeus are cited for their connections to Roman authority. The continuity of the church's teachings through the centuries is highlighted, questioning when communion with Rome became unnecessary. Ultimately, he posits that if Rome maintained its faith, Christians should consider embracing Catholicism.

Explore the intriguing connections between the Finding of Jesus in the Temple and the Resurrection. The discussion delves into the logistics of family travel during Passover and how cultural norms shaped perceptions of child supervision. Uncover the divine purpose behind Jesus' actions, with a focus on Mary’s understanding of his mission. The motif of three days before resurrection foreshadows what was to come, emphasizing Mary's preparedness for the events of Holy Week. A fascinating blend of scripture and cultural context!

Discover why Christmas and the incarnation, though not strictly necessary, hold profound significance. Explore Augustine's intriguing objection about the necessity of God's becoming man. Delve into Aquinas’ insights on fitting versus strict necessity, and uncover five compelling reasons for the incarnation that foster faith, hope, and charity. Learn how Christ’s example inspires moral actions and reveals human dignity. Finally, hear Pope Leo’s inspiring reflections on overcoming fear and embracing transformation through Christ.