Shameless Popery #241 Proving The Catholic Priesthood Is Biblical (Response to Needgod.net)
Jan 15, 2026
In this discussion, the critique of the Catholic priesthood is tackled head-on. Joe emphasizes that Jesus' role as the unique mediator doesn’t exclude human ministers in reconciliation. He explores mediation, confession, and the scriptural basis for a distinct priesthood. Citing biblical texts, he argues that the authority to forgive and the concept of a royal priesthood align with Catholic teaching. Joe also highlights the significance of the Eucharist as a true sacrifice, connecting it to early Christian writings and tradition.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Distinct Kinds Of Mediation
- Joe Heschmeyer distinguishes Christ's unique mediation (ransom on the cross) from human mediation as ministry of reconciliation.
- Human ministers can legitimately bring sinners to Christ without replacing his one saving work.
Check The Actual Teaching First
- Read the Catechism before critiquing Catholic practice because it affirms repentance and faith as prerequisites for absolution.
- Use James 5 and John 20 to understand confession and priestly authority biblically.
High Priest Implies Ministers Exist
- Calling Christ the high priest implies other priests exist, not none; Catholic theology sees other priests as ministers sharing Christ's one priesthood.
- The ministerial priesthood participates in, but doesn't replace, Christ's unique priesthood.