Shameless Popery #237 Why Christmas Was Unnecessary (sorta)
28 snips
Dec 30, 2025 Discover why Christmas and the incarnation, though not strictly necessary, hold profound significance. Explore Augustine's intriguing objection about the necessity of God's becoming man. Delve into Aquinas’ insights on fitting versus strict necessity, and uncover five compelling reasons for the incarnation that foster faith, hope, and charity. Learn how Christ’s example inspires moral actions and reveals human dignity. Finally, hear Pope Leo’s inspiring reflections on overcoming fear and embracing transformation through Christ.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Incarnation Was Fitting, Not Forced
- Christmas (the incarnation) was not strictly necessary because God could have freed humanity other ways.
- But Joe Heschmeyer highlights Augustine: it was the most fitting and best way God chose.
Two Kinds Of Necessity
- St. Thomas Aquinas distinguishes two senses of necessity: strictly required versus fitting and appropriate.
- Joe explains Christmas is not strictly required but is necessary in the sense of being fitting and apt.
Incarnation Makes Faith More Certain
- The incarnation establishes faith by making God's truth visible in history through a real person.
- Joe notes faith remains required, but it's easier to trust God who spoke in the flesh.
