Cultural expectations of traditional masculinity negatively impact men's mental and physical health, leading to lower help-seeking behaviors and higher rates of suicide and violence.
Adherence to traditional masculinity norms is associated with violent behavior, and addressing these norms is crucial in preventing and reducing violence among men.
Deep dives
The impact of traditional masculinity on men's mental and physical health
Traditional masculinity, with its emphasis on being tough, self-reliant, and unemotional, continues to shape men's lives and can have detrimental effects on their mental and physical health. Men are less likely to seek help or have close friendships compared to women, resulting in higher rates of suicide and violence. Research shows that adherence to traditional masculinity norms is associated with violent behavior, such as gun violence and sexual assault. The adherence to these norms is particularly seen in men who score high on measures of traditional masculinity ideology or experience shame and strain when violating these norms. Addressing masculinity and promoting open discussions about emotions can help improve men's mental health and well-being.
The role of traditional masculinity in violence
Traditional masculinity ideology is a key factor in understanding why men are responsible for the majority of violent behavior, even though the majority of men are not violent. Men who conform to traditional masculine norms, particularly those who score high on measures of masculinity, are more likely to exhibit hostility and aggression. Additionally, men who experience shame and strain due to violating masculine norms may also be at risk for engaging in violent behavior. Threatened masculinity, discrepancy strain, and precarious manhood are concepts that link masculinity to violence. These findings highlight the importance of addressing traditional masculinity ideology to prevent and reduce violent behavior.
Promoting change and seeking help
There is a need to challenge and change societal norms surrounding masculinity to promote healthier behaviors and attitudes among men. This can be achieved by fostering environments where boys do not feel obligated to conform to traditional masculine norms and where they feel comfortable expressing vulnerability and seeking help when needed. Encouraging open discussions about emotions and promoting emotional intelligence can also help men develop healthier coping mechanisms. Furthermore, athletes and public figures who openly discuss their mental health struggles can have a positive impact by normalizing help-seeking behaviors and providing role models for men to follow. For individuals seeking professional help, resources such as the National Register of Health Service Providers in Psychology can assist in finding a psychologist who understands and addresses the challenges associated with masculinity and mental health.
Stoic. Self-reliant. Unemotional. For many men, these watchwords of traditional masculinity still hold powerful sway. Men are less likely than women to seek help for mental health issues, they die by suicide more often, and they commit and are the victims of more homicides. Ronald F. Levant, EdD, discusses how cultural expectations of masculinity affect men’s mental and physical health, how our ideas of masculinity have changed over time and what psychologists have learned about how to reach out to men.