UK wine critics Jancis Robinson and Hugh Johnson engage in a lively debate on the virtues of Burgundy and Bordeaux wines. They discuss the characteristics, history, and perception of each region's wines, as well as pricing strategies and trading arrangements. They express concerns about the evolving landscape of Bordeaux wines and the increasing demand for lighter wines.
Read more
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
Bordeaux has a historically commercial approach with extensive production, while Burgundy focuses on terroir-driven wines and distinct vineyard differences.
Burgundy excels in producing transparent and perfumed red wines that express terroir, while recent blind tastings have shown disappointments in quality and value for Bordeaux wines.
Deep dives
The Climate Crisis and the Role of Energized
Energized, a new podcast in partnership with Intelligent Squared and E-Badrola, delves deep into the key issues surrounding the global drive towards net zero and the innovations accelerating the energy transition. The podcast aims to explore solutions to the pressing climate crisis and offers hope in the face of irreversible damage to the planet caused by rising temperatures.
French Wines: Burgundy vs. Bordeaux
In a past debate, two UK wine critics, Jansus Robinson and Hugh Johnson, discussed whether Burgundy or Bordeaux should reign supreme in the world of wine. Each region brings its unique characteristics, with Burgundy offering precise geography and distinct vineyard differences, while Bordeaux shines with its commercial success, extensive production, and aging potential. The debate highlighted the ongoing battle between the two cultures and their enduring rivalry.
Bordeaux's Commercial Approach and Burgundy's Transparence
Bordeaux's approach to winemaking has historically been driven by commerce, targeting the British market and focusing on blending imported grape varieties. Over time, Bordeaux has refined its wines and strived for larger-scale production. On the other hand, Burgundy has maintained its precise geography, with each vineyard expressing different characteristics, and a focus on terroir-driven wines. While Bordeaux has experienced price inflation and struggled to attract younger generations, Burgundy remains consistent and true to its traditional winemaking practices.
The Appeal of Burgundy's Fresher, Lighter Wines
Current trends in the wine world lean toward fresher, lighter wines that express terroir rather than heavy winemaking. Burgundy excels in this regard, offering transparent and perfumed red wines that pair well with food. The region's landscape, with its picturesque villages and vineyard-laden slopes, adds to the overall appeal. In comparison, recent blind tastings of Bordeaux wines have revealed disappointments in terms of quality and value. While Bordeaux struggles to adapt, Burgundy continues to captivate wine enthusiasts with its elegance and accessibility.
Among wine lovers, there is no greater divide than that between Burgundy and Bordeaux. These are the world’s most celebrated wine regions. What separates them and why the great rivalry? Back in 2015 we invited two of the UK's top wine critics, Jancis Robinson and Hugh Johnson, to debate the issue. Chairing the event was Michelin-starred chef and restauranteur Michel Roux Jr.
We’d love to hear your feedback and what you think we should talk about next, who we should have on and what our future debates should be.
Send us an email or voice note with your thoughts to podcasts@intelligencesquared.com or Tweet us @intelligence2.
And if you’d like to get ad-free access to all Intelligence Squared podcasts, including exclusive bonus content, early access to new episodes and much more, become a supporter of Intelligence Squared today for just £4.99, or the equivalent in your local currency .
Just visit intelligencesquared.com/membership to find out more.