Jennifer Pahlka, author of "Recoding America" and founder of Code for America, dives deep into the inefficiencies plaguing government hiring and operations. She reveals how outdated software and rigid hiring practices stifle talent recruitment. The conversation touches on the urgent need for reform, including the potential of AI to streamline processes. Pahlka also discusses the complexities of government budgeting and why simply identifying problems won’t cut it—it's a cultural overhaul that’s essential for real change.
Government operations are often bogged down by outdated technology and bureaucratic inertia, making effective changes challenging.
The rigid hiring processes in government can overlook qualified candidates, favoring those skilled at navigating the system over genuine talent.
Deep dives
The Challenge of Government Spending Efficiency
Government spending is often criticized for inefficiency, with a significant portion of resources failing to yield tangible results. Recent discussions highlight that while it's easy to identify wasteful practices, implementing effective changes is considerably more difficult. Many organizations, including government entities, often find themselves entangled in bureaucratic red tape, making it challenging to enact reforms or optimize spending processes. The frustration surrounding high spending without corresponding benefits has led citizens to demand more accountability and efficiency from their governments.
Barriers to Upgrading Government Technology
Government technology projects frequently encounter barriers due to excessive complexity and a reliance on outdated systems. For instance, the Department of Defense is burdened by over 5,000 accounting systems that inhibit streamlined processes. Requirements introduced by Congress often lead to bespoke software solutions instead of adopting standard commercial options, complicating procurement and maintenance. This approach prevents innovation and efficiency, leaving government agencies struggling to adapt to modern technological needs.
Obstacles in Government Hiring Processes
The government hiring process is often hindered by rigid self-assessment criteria that overlook candidates' actual skills and qualifications. Many hiring managers lack the authority to assess applicants meaningfully, relying on HR departments that prioritize compliance over effective selection. This disconnect can lead to qualified candidates being eliminated based on mismatched terminologies or formats in their resumes. Ultimately, the process can end up favoring those who are adept at navigating the system rather than those with genuine talent and capability.
The Need for Disruptive Change in Bureaucracy
There is an increasing call for transformative, rather than incremental, changes to address the inefficiencies within government bureaucracy. Participants in discussions have noted that recognizing issues alone is insufficient for meaningful reform; bold actions may be necessary to dismantle entrenched processes that stifle progress. While there are concerns about radical approaches, proponents suggest that a shake-up could help overcome the inertia found in bureaucratic systems. By addressing both the 'what' and the 'how' of governance, there is potential for a more effective and responsive government.
Regardless of your political ideology, it's easy to agree that government should work well; that it should be able to hire talented officials, and build things in a timely, cost-effective manner. Of course, what that means in practice is open for debate, and different people will have different priorities. But at the moment, there are reasons to believe the public sector isn't operating optimally. Things move incredibly slow in many cases. Software systems are often old and extremely costly, and don't do a good job serving the public's needs. It can be extremely difficult to bring on the best workers, even setting aside questions about public sector salaries. Jennifer Pahlka is the author of Recoding America, and was the founder of Code for America. She has also served as the US Deputy Chief CTO and has seen how much of government operates up close. We talk to her about what she's seen, how waste happens, how government operations get bogged down by inertia, and why simply identifying things that are going wrong isn't enough to change them. She talks to us about Elon Musk's Department of Government Efficiency, and why a major jolt may be necessary to get better results.
Only Bloomberg.com subscribers can get the Odd Lots newsletter in their inbox — now delivered every weekday — plus unlimited access to the site and app. Subscribe at bloomberg.com/subscriptions/oddlots