Different accounts of Judas's death in Acts and Matthew highlight discrepancies in biblical narratives.
Interpretive choices by authors in biblical stories emphasize theological motifs and fulfillment of prophecies.
Deep dives
Comparison of Judas's Death in Acts and Matthew
In Acts, Judas buys a field with his reward, falls headlong, bursting open, resulting in the field being called the Field of Blood. Meanwhile, in Matthew, Judas returns the 30 pieces of silver, hanged himself, and the priests used the money to buy a potter's field, fulfilling a prophecy from Zechariah.
Divergent Narratives
Acts presents a concise and gruesome account of Judas's death, mentioning the gory details of his body bursting open after falling headlong. Conversely, Matthew expands the story with the return of silver, Judas's suicide, and the purchase of a field, aligning it with a prophecy and introducing theological implications.
Interpretation and Apologetics
The conflicting stories of Judas's death present challenges in harmonization, leading to apologetic attempts to reconcile the divergent narratives. The differences highlight the interpretive choices made by the authors, emphasizing theological motifs and fulfilling prophecies.
Papius's Legendary Account
Papius of Hierapolis offers an eccentric account of Judas's death, describing him swelling up and bursting on his property, with graphic details of maggots and stench lingering for centuries. This exaggerated narrative adds a legendary element to the various depictions of Judas's demise.
Call Ted Danson, because this week we're going to the bad place. Does the Bible really threaten sinners and nonbelievers with eternal torment? Was the idea of hell made up long after the Bible was written? Get out your asbestos snorkle and mask, because we're going to probe deep into the lake of eternal fire, and see what we can find.
Then, it's "what ever happened to baby Judas" as we look at two Biblical accounts of how brother Iscariot met his earthly end, and realize they don't quite match up. Do you yearn for redemption for the wayward apostle, or are you hungry for revenge? There's a story to fit any appetite.
If you want to support our work, please consider becoming a monthly patron at:
