

Data Over Dogma
Daniel McClellan and Daniel Beecher
This ain't your pastor's Bible podcast. This is a deep interrogation of the book, and we're bringing receipts. Bible scholar Dr. Dan McClellan and atheist podcaster Dan Beecher team up to discover what the Bible actually says, what it decidedly doesn't say (even if everyone thinks it does), and explore the history of the most popular book of all time.
Episodes
Mentioned books

18 snips
Dec 1, 2025 • 1h 2min
Polygamy!
This week, the discussion dives into a provocative claim by a Missouri pastor about the Bible supporting polygamy. They explore key biblical passages, debating whether scripture truly endorses plural marriage. Solomon and his son Rehoboam's tumultuous reigns are also examined, revealing the consequences of foreign wives and poor leadership choices. The hosts navigate cultural backlash against Mormon polygyny and analyze the shifts in both Judaism and Christianity regarding marriage practices. It's a thought-provoking journey through scriptural interpretations and historical context!

10 snips
Nov 24, 2025 • 55min
Who Deserves to Eat?
This discussion dives into the controversial verse from 2 Thessalonians that suggests those unwilling to work shouldn't eat. The hosts explore how it's often misused politically to justify denying aid to the needy. They contrast this with broader biblical teachings that advocate for caring for the poor. Shifting gears, the conversation examines the Hyksos, Semitic rulers of ancient Egypt, probing their connection to the Exodus narrative and dissecting popular legends surrounding figures like Joseph. It's an engaging blend of biblical critique and historical inquiry!

33 snips
Nov 17, 2025 • 59min
It's a Jubilee!
Celebrate the fascinating Book of Jubilees, a unique retelling of Genesis with angelic narration and a new calendar! Discover how it smooths biblical tensions and proposes a 364-day year for festivals. Transitioning to a viral claim, the hosts dissect the concept of 63,779 perfect cross-references in the Bible. They reveal how these links are constructed, arguing against the notion of divine authorship while exploring how human composition shapes the text. Join in for a lively exploration of faith, history, and textual complexities!

61 snips
Nov 10, 2025 • 1h 7min
Close Encounters of the Catholic Kind
In this engaging discussion, Michael Peppard, a theology professor at Fordham University and author of 'How Catholics Encounter the Bible', explores how Catholics interact with the Bible beyond reading. He highlights the multisensory experience of Mass and the underrepresentation of women and Judaism in the lectionary. Peppard also examines the role of visual art in conveying biblical narratives and critiques how historical changes, like the Reformation, have shaped Catholic biblical understanding. Join them for a fresh perspective on faith and encounter!

23 snips
Nov 3, 2025 • 1h 5min
Should Wives Submit?
The hosts dive into the controversial topic of Ephesians 5, questioning the notion of wives submitting to husbands and exploring the ancient Greek language nuances that change its interpretation. They discuss how mutual submission is framed within the text and critique the historical context of household codes. Then, the conversation takes a wild turn into ancient aliens, analyzing biblical texts for extraterrestrial connections. From Sitchin's theories to Ezekiel's visions, the hosts tackle bizarre claims while emphasizing the importance of rhetorical imagery.

15 snips
Oct 27, 2025 • 53min
Don't Get Cross With Me
Explore the intriguing evolution of the cross as a Christian symbol, revealing its historical significance and early alternatives like the fish and anchor. Delve into the debate surrounding the shape of the cross that Jesus was crucified on, as well as the shocking truth about how crucifixion was practiced in ancient Rome. The discussion then shifts to Ecclesiastes 11:5, unpacking varied interpretations and linking them to concepts of ensoulment, all while showcasing the challenges of biblical translation.

7 snips
Oct 20, 2025 • 1h 12min
The Adult(ery) Episode
This week dives into the controversial interpretation of adultery in the Ten Commandments and its historical context in the Hebrew Bible. The hosts analyze how ancient views framed adultery as property rights, contrasting it with modern moral standards. They also explore the provocative story of Hosea, including God's command to marry a prostitute and its symbolic implications for Israel's fidelity. The discussion touches on themes of punishment and restoration, revealing the enduring relevance of these biblical narratives.

44 snips
Oct 13, 2025 • 1h 1min
Peter Thiel is Bankrupt! (Theologically)
Peter Thiel claims the Antichrist is on the way, but his interpretation raises eyebrows. The hosts dissect his ACT 17 manifesto's biblical roots and question its intent for Silicon Valley elites. They explore how Thiel’s investments clash with his fears of centralized power. The discussion shifts to the Star of David, unraveling its history and debunking antisemitic conspiracy theories linking it to child sacrifice. The podcast highlights the misuse of scriptural references and the distortion of symbols in modern narratives.

30 snips
Oct 6, 2025 • 56min
You Want a Boat? I Noah Guy
Dive into the fascinating world of Noah's ark as the hosts explore conflicting narratives from antiquity. They dissect the descriptions of Noah amidst divine judgment and discuss the ark's construction details, including varying animal counts. The analysis reveals intriguing contradictions in timelines and the implications of the flood story's sources. Transitioning to the New Testament, they unpack the parable of the rich fool, warning against hoarding wealth while emphasizing the importance of generosity. A blend of storytelling and critical examination awaits!

29 snips
Sep 29, 2025 • 49min
Blessed Baruch!
Dive into the intriguing world of Baruch, an enigmatic book linked to Jeremiah. Explore its historical context—was it really written during the exile? Discover the odd prayers urging support for Babylonian rulers, and unravel how the wisdom within connects to the Torah. Delve into its composition and the fascinating reasons behind its mixed reception across Jewish and Christian traditions. This episode is a whirlwind of scholarship, exploring how Baruch shaped identities and influenced canon choices.


