The 3b1b podcast
3 - Steven Strogatz: In and out of love with math
Episode guests
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
- Intuition plays a crucial role in teaching math and inspiring students to develop a love for the subject, focusing on understanding the questions and concepts behind math rather than just providing answers.
- Motivation to pursue math can come from various sources such as exploring real-world applications, appreciating the beauty and logic of mathematical concepts, understanding the history and context of math, or recognizing its potential career opportunities.
- Supportive mentors and personal passion are key factors in shaping one's path as a mathematician, highlighting the transformative impact of following one's love for math and delving deep into the subject.
- Balancing rigor and intuition in mathematical exposition, prioritizing clarity and engagement over strict conciseness, and focusing on audience understanding and engagement can greatly enhance teaching and learning experiences in math.
Deep dives
Discovering the Passion for Mathematics
The podcast episode explores Stephen Strogatz's journey into mathematics and his love for the subject. Strogatz recounts how he fell in love with math in high school and his early experiences with complex analysis and differential geometry. Despite facing discouragement and pressure to pursue other paths, Strogatz's passion for math led him to explore research opportunities, including a problem related to the topology of DNA. He also discusses the importance of intuition in teaching and inspiring students.
The Challenge of Introducing Math Exposition
Strogatz emphasizes the role of intuition in teaching math and how it can help students develop a love for the subject. He highlights the importance of helping students understand the questions and concepts behind math rather than just focusing on providing answers. Strogatz shares personal experiences of being inspired by excellent teachers who focused on intuitive explanations and how those moments had a profound impact on his own learning and interest in the subject.
The Complexity of Motivating Math Enthusiasm
Strogatz acknowledges that different approaches may resonate with different students in terms of fostering a love for math. He discusses how motivation can come from various sources, such as understanding the history and context of math, exploring real-world applications, appreciating the beauty and logic behind mathematical concepts, or even recognizing the potential career opportunities math can offer. Strogatz also stresses the importance of intuition in teaching, as it can provide a satisfying sense of understanding and accomplishment.
The Liberating Power of Following Your Passion
Strogatz shares personal anecdotes about the pivotal moments that shaped his path as a mathematician. He recounts how he initially faced discouragement and shifted his focus to pre-med courses but realized his true love for math. He discusses the importance of having supportive mentors who encouraged him to pursue his passion and make independent decisions about his academic and career choices. Strogatz emphasizes the transformative impact of following one's passion and the joy and fulfillment that come from delving deep into a subject of personal interest.
Understanding the Zeta Function Formula and Euler's Product
Euler has a formula for the zeta function that involves an infinite product, with prime numbers appearing in it. The proof of this formula is often given in a concise and inscrutable one-sentence form, which lacks intuition and clarity. However, an alternative proof utilizing the sieve of Eratosthenes offers a more intuitive and understandable approach. This proof demonstrates the connection between the zeta function and primes in a straightforward manner, highlighting the beauty and elegance of the mathematical relationship.
Emphasizing Concrete Examples over Abstraction
When teaching mathematics, it is crucial to prioritize concrete examples over abstract generalizations. Starting with specific instances and using them as motivation can help students better understand and appreciate the underlying concepts. By presenting relatable and engaging examples, teachers can foster a deeper connection with the subject matter and encourage active learning.
Challenging the Culture of Rigor at the Expense of Intuition
The culture of mathematics often places an excessive emphasis on rigor, which can overshadow the importance of intuition and clarity in mathematical exposition. The pressure to focus solely on rigor and conciseness in proofs and presentations can hinder effective communication and impede the comprehension of mathematical ideas. Encouraging a balance between rigor and intuition, and valuing clarity and engagement in mathematical exposition, can lead to more effective teaching and learning experiences.
Shifting the Expository Focus from Ego to Engagement
In mathematical lectures and presentations, there is a tendency to prioritize individual achievements and impressiveness over engaging and enlightening the audience. Shifting the focus from personal ego to audience engagement and understanding can significantly improve mathematical exposition. Encouraging presenters to discuss beautiful work by colleagues, motivating examples, and open problems instead of concentrating solely on their own achievements can foster a more inclusive and inspiring learning environment.
Steven Strogatz, an applied mathematician at Cornell, is a prominent figure in the field of nonlinear dynamics and chaos, and a widely beloved popularizer of math.
Episode sponsor: https://brilliant.org/3b1b
Brilliant is a great site/app for being more active in learning math.
--- Books by Strogatz which we discussed ---
Chaos and Nonlinear dynamics
https://amzn.to/3lFQjrU
Infinite powers
https://amzn.to/3AnvXIg
Unpublished appendix about Newton's letters to Leibniz:
https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5436e695e4b07f1e91b30155/t/5dd434fb9d105d031ded69de/1574188283323/Appendix+2+-+Newton+on+infinite+series+and+the+Epistola+Posterior+v4.pdf
--- Other things which came up ---
Strogatz's senior thesis:
https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5436e695e4b07f1e91b30155/t/5dca1c993141bb5946c54b45/1573526688118/The-mathematics-of-supercoiled-DNA.pdf
His first published paper:
https://www.pnas.org/content/pnas/78/3/1461.full.pdf
Crick’s paper about linking numbers and nucleosomes with the memorable comment that inspired his experiment with the ribbon:
https://www.pnas.org/content/pnas/73/8/2639.full.pdf
The 4-dog chase problem and its solution.
https://www.theguardian.com/science/2019/jun/03/can-you-solve-it-dogs-in-pursuit
https://www.theguardian.com/science/2019/jun/03/did-you-solve-it-dogs-in-pursuit
For a full solution with calculus, see Strogatz's book "The Calculus of Friendship"
https://amzn.to/3CyVe48
Survey for kids on their desired occupation:
https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/lego-group-kicks-off-global-program-to-inspire-the-next-generation-of-space-explorers-as-nasa-celebrates-50-years-of-moon-landing-300885423.html
A radical approach to real analysis
https://amzn.to/2VwtgF3
Twitter thread on what, morally, a normal subgroup is.
https://mobile.twitter.com/sbagley/status/1296211024534622208
Leibniz formula via patterns from primes
https://youtu.be/NaL_Cb42WyY
--- Table of contents ---
0:00 - Intro
1:15 - Ad
1:59 - The perfect problem for a high school student
12:43 - Starting the Princeton undergrad
22:52 - The most beautiful proof
26:58 - What makes someone love a problem?
36:05 - Putting lessons online
41:57 - In and out of pre-med
47:05 - The geometry of DNA
58:53 - Using teaching as a means to learn
1:09:47 - Do students like history?
1:18:39 - The truth of Newton and Leibniz
1:23:29 - Archimedes, a true great
1:28:32 - Pitfalls of pure math exposition
1:39:03 - "Morality" in math
1:43:20 - An under-motivated culture
1:51:48 - What's next?
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
