Robert Sapolsky on the toxic intersection of poverty and stress
Jan 24, 2019
01:21:09
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
Chronic stress impairs brain function impacting decision-making and emotional regulation.
Poverty's link to poor health is mediated by stress and societal inequality.
Learned helplessness perpetuates poverty by hindering problem-solving abilities through stress-induced impairments.
Deep dives
Impact of Chronic Stress on Mental and Physical Health
Chronic stress, whether from short-term crises or long-term psychological pressures, plays a detrimental role in mental and physical health by impairing the prefrontal cortex, affecting decision-making, impulse control, and emotional regulation. Prolonged stress leads to atrophy of the prefrontal cortex and hippocampus, disrupting memory, learning, and executive function. The stress response can also enhance fear and anxiety through the overactivation of the amygdala, contributing to a range of stress-related disorders including PTSD. Moreover, stress can cause vulnerabilities in the brain from an early age, influencing a person's lifelong cognitive and emotional functioning.
Poverty's Impact on Health and Socioeconomic Status
The relationship between poverty and health outcomes extends beyond material conditions, with stress being a primary mediator of poor health in impoverished individuals. Poverty is associated with worse health outcomes independent of factors like healthcare access or lifestyle choices, indicating the pervasive impact of stress. Moreover, subjective social status, feelings of poverty amidst societal wealth, and societal inequality significantly contribute to health disparities, highlighting the psychological dimensions of poverty's influence on well-being.
Learned Helplessness, Poverty, and Social Mobility
Learned helplessness, exemplified by the cycle of anxiety turning into depression, can perpetuate poverty by diminishing problem-solving capacities through stress-induced impairments in brain function. Strategies to combat learned helplessness, such as bypassing conditioned beliefs through novel approaches like learning Mandarin Chinese, offer insights into addressing the psychological barriers that perpetuate poverty. The interaction between poverty and stress weakens individuals' abilities to cope and make sound decisions, further entrenching economic hardship and hindering social mobility.
Impact of Inequality on Social Capital and Health
Social capital, which involves trust and a sense of efficacy in society, plays a crucial role in determining health outcomes. Studies show that increased income inequality leads to decreased social capital, impacting everyone's health. In societies with reduced trust and efficacy, rates of illnesses, crime, and other negative outcomes rise, affecting the overall well-being of individuals.
Role of Complex Systems in Shaping Society
Understanding complex systems, as explored in James Gleick's book 'Chaos,' profoundly influences thinking about how various systems, including biological and societal, function. The book delves into the intricate workings of complex systems like cells, brains, and ecosystems, offering insights into the dynamics of diverse interacting components and their impact on the world.
Robert Sapolsky is a Stanford neuroscientist and primatologist. He’s the author of a slew of important books on human biology and behavior. But it’s an older book he wrote that forms the basis for this conversation. In Why Zebras Don’t Get Ulcers, Sapolsky works through how a stress response that evolved for fast, fight-or-flight situations on the savannah continuously wears on our bodies and brains in modern life.
But stress isn’t just an individual phenomenon. It’s also a social force, applied brutally and unequally across our society. “If you want to see an example of chronic stress, study poverty,” Sapolsky says.
I often say on the show that politics and policy need to begin with a realistic model of human nature. This is a show about that level of the policy conversation: It’s about how poverty and stress exist in a doom loop together, each amplifying the other’s effects on the brain and body, deepening their harms.
And this is a conversation of intense relevance to how we make social policy. Much of the fight in Washington, and in the states, is about whether the best way to get people out of poverty is to make it harder to access help, to make sure the government doesn’t become, in Paul Ryan’s memorable phrase, “a hammock.” Understanding how the stress of poverty acts on people’s minds, how it saps their will and harms their cognitive function and hurts their children, exposes how cruel and wrongheaded that view really is.
Sapolsky and I also discuss whether free will is a myth, why he believes the prison system is incompatible with modern neuroscience, how studying monkeys in times of social change helps makes sense of the current moment in American politics, and much more. This one’s worth your time.