Past Present Future

To kick off our new series on the history of bad ideas David talks to historian Sophie Scott-Brown about the idea of ‘the silent majority’, beloved by American presidents from Nixon to Trump. Where does this idea come from? Is it conservative or revolutionary? If the majority are actually silent, how can anyone know what they are thinking? And aren’t the silent majority really the dead?Looking for Christmas presents? We have a special Xmas gift offer: give a subscription to PPF+ and your recipient will also receive a personally inscribed copy of David’s new book The History of Ideas. Find out more https://www.ppfideas.com/giftsNext up on Bad Ideas: Nobel Prizes Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Gary Gerstle, a historian, explores the historical significance of Donald Trump’s recent election victory. He discusses how this unexpected outcome parallels past U.S. elections, particularly the influence of inflation and immigration. Gerstle raises critical questions about democracy's survival amidst political mistrust and the challenges of mass deportation proposals. He also examines shifts in voter dynamics, highlighting Trump's appeal to traditionally Democratic demographics, and reflects on the potential future of the Republican Party in this new political landscape.

Dive into the revolutionary impact of Gillo Pontecorvo’s The Battle of Algiers, a film that redefined political cinema. Explore its gripping portrayal of the Algerian independence struggle and the stark realities facing oppressed communities. The nuanced depiction of violence and identity highlights moral complexities, particularly through the stories of courageous women. Discover how the film reflects historical tensions and its cautionary insights on resistance movements. Plus, a teaser about an upcoming discussion on Apocalypse Now!

Jill Lepore, an esteemed American historian, delves into the dark humor of Stanley Kubrick's 'Dr. Strangelove' and the chilling gravity of Sidney Lumet's 'Fail Safe.' She explores the absurdity of political authority during the Cold War and critiques the cultural dynamics portrayed in these films. The conversation highlights the tension between military protocol and moral choices in a nuclear crisis. Lepore also discusses how these classics resonate with today's technological challenges, emphasizing the need for thoughtful storytelling in modern politics.

Lucia Rubinelli, an Italian historian of ideas and expert on 20th-century Italian culture, joins to discuss Luchino Visconti’s film, The Leopard. They explore how a communist aristocrat created a narrative of Sicilian identity during Italian unification. Topics include the meaning behind the famous line about change, the interplay of opulence and disillusionment in the film's grand ball, and contrasts between Sicilian and Northern Italian perspectives on life and death. The conversation unveils how the film critiques political cynicism and reflects societal dynamics.

Dive into the chilling depths of Cold War anxiety with a classic film that eerily mirrors its time. Explore the disturbing themes of brainwashing, McCarthyism, and the psychological struggles of its characters. The romantic entanglements are as surreal as the political manipulation, highlighting a critique of societal norms. Plus, there’s an intriguing look at why many American presidents love a certain classic western. Unravel the layers of power and control that resonate through both the film and today’s politics!

Dive into a WWII classic that intertwines romance with the harsh realities of conflict. Explore the complexities of Clive Wynne Candy, the film's nuanced protagonist, as he grapples with nostalgia and disillusionment. Discover why Churchill wanted the film halted and whether his suspicions about its messaging were warranted. The themes of outdated heroism and evolving patriotism resonate throughout, while a sneak peek at presidential film favorites hints at intriguing cultural connections.

Orson Welles's Citizen Kane shines a light on the intricate dance between celebrity and political power. The podcast explores Donald Trump's admiration for the film, probing what he misses about Kane's complex character. Themes of ambition and the quest for love are dissected, revealing the tragic flaws of the media mogul. The discussion draws compelling parallels between Kane's downfall and contemporary political figures, highlighting the timeless struggles of power, identity, and public perception.

Dive into the charming yet complex world of a classic political film that explores the battle between the idealistic underdog and a corrupt establishment. Discover how the character of Jefferson Smith mirrors historical figures, shedding light on themes of political innocence versus cynicism. The discussion extends into the intricacies of the filibuster and the influence of public opinion, revealing the duality of democracy. It’s a thought-provoking examination of integrity, corruption, and the evolution of American politics.

Dive into Jean Renoir's 'La Grande Illusion,' a poignant anti-war film that questions the rationale behind conflict. Explore the intricate human relationships formed under the strains of World War I, revealing the absurdity of war and the shared humanity that transcends national boundaries. Enjoy a powerful scene where French prisoners sing 'La Marseillaise' defiantly, highlighting fleeting moments of triumph amidst despair. The podcast delves into the tragic ironies of love and loyalty, setting the stage for a deeper discussion about political narratives.