The History of Revolutionary Ideas: English Revolution 1: Civil War
Feb 13, 2025
auto_awesome
Clare Jackson, a historian specializing in the English Civil War, joins the discussion to unpack this pivotal conflict. They explore whether the Civil War qualifies as a revolution and highlight Scotland's resistance to Charles I. The emergence of radical ideas from groups like the Levellers is examined, along with the monumental impact of Charles I's execution on English liberties. Jackson sheds light on the complexity of power dynamics at play and reflects on England's brief experiment with republicanism during this tumultuous period.
The English Civil War's naming reflects its complex nature, evolving from 'rebellion' to 'revolution' over the centuries as perspectives shifted.
Revolutionary sentiments were catalyzed by Scottish resistance against King Charles I, illustrating interconnected dynamics across England, Scotland, and Ireland.
The trial and execution of King Charles I in 1649 challenged monarchy's divine right, paving the way for republican ideals in English political thought.
Deep dives
The Complexity of Naming the Revolution
The discussion highlights the various names attributed to the 17th-century English Civil War, reflecting its complex nature. The term 'English Revolution' was not coined until the 20th century, with historians like Guizot drawing parallels to the French Revolution. In contrast, earlier works, such as those by Edward Hyde, referred to it as a rebellion. The conversation emphasizes the importance of nomenclature, as the perceptions of this period evolved, and points out that it was not universally considered a revolution until much later.
The Role of the Scottish Revolutionaries
The podcast discusses how the roots of revolutionary sentiment during the English Civil War may have originated in Scotland. Scottish citizens were among the first to resist King Charles I, particularly in response to his attempts to impose religious uniformity. This resistance spurred English action and can be seen as a catalyst for the English Civil War itself. The interconnected dynamics among England, Scotland, and Ireland illustrate that the revolutionary impulses were not limited to England alone.
The Emergence of a Professional Army
The creation of the New Model Army marked a significant turning point during the conflict, changing the dynamics of power and authority. Unlike local militias, this army operated independently and had a strong sense of identity and professionalism. As the civil war progressed, the army began to challenge the parliamentary establishment, demanding more radical reforms. The rupture between parliamentarian leaders and military leaders ultimately led to a breakdown in negotiations and the execution of King Charles I.
The Trial and Execution of Charles I
The trial and execution of King Charles I in 1649 represented a radical departure from traditional monarchy, creating a precedent for questioning the divine right of kings. The decision to treat the king like any other criminal was unprecedented and shocked both English citizens and foreign observers. This moment crystallized the ideological battle between monarchy and emerging republican ideals, altering the relationship between the state and its monarchy. The trial symbolized a significant shift in political thought, as well as a potential turn towards republicanism.
Legacy of Revolutionary Ideas Post-Restoration
Despite the Restoration of the monarchy under Charles II, the revolutionary period left a lasting impact on English political thought. The era saw the emergence of radical ideas that challenged existing norms, such as those proposed by the Levellers advocating for greater political representation and rights. The memory of the English Civil War and its violent outcomes instilled a wariness of unchecked power, especially military authority. As a result, the tension between royal power and the rights of subjects continued to inspire political discourse long after the Civil War ended.
Today’s episode in our history of revolutionary ideas is about the event that is sometimes – but not always – called the English Revolution: the Civil War of the 1640s and the short-lived republic that followed. David talks to historian Clare Jackson about whether this really was a revolution and about the thinking that inspired it. What was old, what was new, what was borrowed and what was left when it was all over – what happened to the dreams of a brave new world?
Out tomorrow: the latest edition of our free fortnightly newsletter with guides to the most recent episodes, links, clips and further reading: sign up now https://www.ppfideas.com/newsletters
Tickets are available for PPF Live at the Bath Curious Minds Festival: on Saturday March 29th David will be in conversation with Robert Saunders about the legacy of Winston Churchill: The Politician with Nine Lives https://bit.ly/42GPp3X
Next up in The History of Revolutionary Ideas: English Revolution 2: 1688
Past Present Future is part of the Airwave Podcast Network