Open to Debate
Open to Debate
America is more divided than ever—but it doesn’t have to be. Open to Debate offers an antidote to the chaos. We bring multiple perspectives together for real, nonpartisan debates. Debates that are structured, respectful, clever, provocative, and driven by the facts. Open to Debate is on a mission to restore balance to the public square through expert moderation, good-faith arguments, and reasoned analysis. We examine the issues of the day with the world’s most influential thinkers spanning science, technology, politics, culture, and global affairs. It’s time to build a stronger, more united democracy with the civil exchange of ideas. Be open-minded. Be curious. Be ready to listen. Join us in being Open to Debate. (Formerly Intelligence Squared U.S.)
Episodes
Mentioned books
4 snips
Oct 3, 2025 • 54min
Wartime Kill Switch: Human or AI?
Laura Walker McDonald highlights the need for human control in warfare to protect civilians and ensure accountability. Michael C. Horowitz argues that AI can enhance compliance with humanitarian law and reduce emotional mistakes. Elliot Ackerman emphasizes the moral implications of war and the necessity for ethical leadership. Meanwhile, Jack Shanahan discusses the inevitability of autonomous systems and the importance of human oversight throughout the AI lifecycle. Together, they delve into the complex debate over the roles of humans and AI in modern warfare.
75 snips
Sep 26, 2025 • 53min
Debating the Legacy of the COVID-19 Pandemic
Dr. Jerome Adams, former U.S. Surgeon General, shares insights on public health communication failures and societal challenges during COVID-19. Dr. Mike Varshavski, known as Dr. Mike, highlights systemic issues that contributed to the crisis. Dr. Dara Kass recounts her frontline experiences and the misinformation that hindered collective action. Dr. Tom Frieden, ex-CDC Director, emphasizes the importance of effective communication and the need for future public health investments. The debate raises critical questions about accountability and the role of society in managing health crises.
22 snips
Sep 12, 2025 • 54min
Is Masculinity A Prison?
In this lively debate, Mike Pesca, a seasoned journalist known for his daily news insights on The Gist, argues that masculinity is evolving and not a prison. Opposing him, Lux Alptraum, a writer and sex educator, emphasizes how rigid masculine roles can lead to emotional isolation. They explore the influence of cultural figures and the term 'toxic masculinity' on men's identities. The discussion also tackles personal experiences and societal pressures facing men today, making for a thought-provoking conversation on masculinity's role in modern life.
23 snips
Sep 10, 2025 • 53min
TikTok in the Classroom: Enhancing or Eroding the Teaching Profession?
In this engaging discussion, Phil Cook, a high school chemistry teacher and TikTok influencer, argues for the platform's potential in making learning more accessible. In contrast, Adrian Dingle, an education consultant and chemistry author, raises concerns about distractions and diminishing educational depth. The two explore the balance between utilizing modern technology for engagement and adhering to rigorous teaching standards, revealing a lively debate on TikTok's role in today's classrooms.
76 snips
Sep 5, 2025 • 1h 19min
Should the U.S. Be Ruled by a CEO Dictator?
In this thought-provoking discussion, Curtis Yarvin, a political philosopher and tech entrepreneur, argues for the efficiency of a CEO-style dictatorship in the U.S. He believes it could disrupt outdated institutions. In contrast, E. Glen Weyl, co-founder of the Radical Exchange Foundation, warns that such centralization compromises democratic values. They explore historical precedents, legal frameworks, media-government dynamics, and the risks of power concentration. This fierce debate challenges listeners to reconsider the essence of American governance.
38 snips
Sep 2, 2025 • 53min
Don't Eat Anything With a Face
In this engaging discussion, Neal Barnard, a clinical researcher and founder of the Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine, teams up with Gene Baur, president of the Farm Sanctuary, to argue for a plant-based lifestyle. Conversely, Chris Masterjohn, a nutritional sciences researcher, and Joel Salatin, a farmer and author, passionately defend meat consumption. They explore the ethics of eating animals, the health impacts of diets, and the environmental consequences, all while addressing personal choices and the complexities of our dietary habits.
14 snips
Aug 26, 2025 • 52min
Fast Fashion: Shop or Stop?
Katherine Mangu-Ward, Editor-in-Chief at Reason, champions the affordability and accessibility of fast fashion, arguing it supports jobs and economic growth. Meanwhile, Kenneth Pucker, former COO of Timberland and sustainability professor, raises alarm bells about environmental damage and worker exploitation linked to the industry. The discussion unpacks the ethical dilemma of choosing trendy clothing versus sustainable practices, urging listeners to consider the broader impact of their shopping habits.
55 snips
Aug 19, 2025 • 53min
Is Our Productivity Culture Toxic?
Jennifer Moss, a workplace culture expert, discusses the rise of burnout and stresses the need for healthier environments. Amy Edmondson focuses on psychological safety in organizations, while David Allen shares his stress-free productivity methods. Rahaf Harfoush critiques the relentless hustle culture shaped by technology, highlighting its societal impacts. They debate whether our obsession with productivity is toxic or if it's our definitions of success that need rethinking, encouraging a shift towards meaningful work and collective success.
27 snips
Aug 12, 2025 • 53min
Is It Time for the Catholic Church to Ordain Women as Deacons?
Pia de Solenni, a theologian and former chancellor of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Orange, argues against the ordination of women as deacons, highlighting theological implications and the current roles women play in the Church. Conversely, Casey Stanton from Discerning Deacons advocates for women’s ordination, citing historical precedents and a push for modern inclusivity. The discussion delves into early Church traditions, the evolving role of women, and the potential for reform within Catholicism amid changing societal expectations.
Aug 5, 2025 • 53min
Think Twice: The Idaho Four Tragedy with Vicky Ward
Vicky Ward, an Emmy-winning journalist and co-author of 'The Idaho Four: An American Tragedy,' dives into the complexities surrounding the tragic murder of four University of Idaho students. She explores the emotional toll on victims' families amid rampant online speculation and the role of investigative genealogy in solving the case. Vicky discusses communication failures between police and journalists, the implications of incel ideology, and the epidemic of male loneliness linked to these events. Her insights urge listeners to reflect on broader societal themes.
