

Assess THAT with Tom & Nat! (Assessment, Feedback, Grading, and Learning)
Tom Schimmer
Assess THAT with Tom & Nat is a bi-weekly podcast where co-hosts Tom Schimmer and Natalie Vardabasso unpack what it really means to deepen assessment literacy in schools. Known for their dynamic, insightful, and sometimes provocative conversations, Tom and Nat create a space where educators can rethink grading, feedback, and accountability in ways that put student learning first. Each episode blends practical strategies with big-picture thinking, helping teachers and leaders translate research into action without losing sight of the human side of education.
Listeners can expect honest discussions, fresh perspectives, and plenty of take-home ideas. From reimagining final exams to exploring the role of assessment in equity and Universal Design for Learning, Assess THAT is for any educator ready to challenge the status quo and embrace assessment as a tool for growth—not just measurement.
About the HostsTom Schimmer and Natalie Vardabasso are internationally recognized speakers, authors, and consultants who have spent their careers helping schools modernize assessment and grading practices. Together, they are the co-founders of the Canadian Assessment Centre (CAC), a national professional learning hub created by Canadians, for Canadians to bring clarity, credibility, and care to assessment in classrooms across the country.
Tom Schimmer is the author and co-author of multiple best-selling books, including Grading from the Inside Out and Standards-Based Learning in Action. With 35 years of experience as a teacher, leader, and consultant, Tom is known for his ability to translate big ideas into practical tools educators can use right away.
Natalie Vardabasso is a leading voice in assessment and equity, recognized for her innovative approaches to standards-based learning, feedback, and student agency. As a speaker, writer, and coach, she has helped thousands of educators create assessment systems that are not only accurate but also deeply humanizing.
Together, Tom and Natalie bring complementary perspectives, humour, and a deep commitment to making assessment meaningful. Their partnership in Assess THAT and at the Canadian Assessment Centre reflects a shared belief that when educators improve how they assess, they unlock the full potential of every learner.
Tom and Natalie are also the authors of Rehumanizing Assessment: Gathering Evidence of Learning Through Storytelling, a book that challenges traditional grading systems and shows how assessment can honour student voice and identity.
Why Listen?Whether you’re a classroom teacher, school leader, or policy maker, Assess THAT with Tom & Nat will challenge your assumptions, equip you with actionable strategies, and inspire you to see assessment as the most powerful driver of student success.
Listeners can expect honest discussions, fresh perspectives, and plenty of take-home ideas. From reimagining final exams to exploring the role of assessment in equity and Universal Design for Learning, Assess THAT is for any educator ready to challenge the status quo and embrace assessment as a tool for growth—not just measurement.
About the HostsTom Schimmer and Natalie Vardabasso are internationally recognized speakers, authors, and consultants who have spent their careers helping schools modernize assessment and grading practices. Together, they are the co-founders of the Canadian Assessment Centre (CAC), a national professional learning hub created by Canadians, for Canadians to bring clarity, credibility, and care to assessment in classrooms across the country.
Tom Schimmer is the author and co-author of multiple best-selling books, including Grading from the Inside Out and Standards-Based Learning in Action. With 35 years of experience as a teacher, leader, and consultant, Tom is known for his ability to translate big ideas into practical tools educators can use right away.
Natalie Vardabasso is a leading voice in assessment and equity, recognized for her innovative approaches to standards-based learning, feedback, and student agency. As a speaker, writer, and coach, she has helped thousands of educators create assessment systems that are not only accurate but also deeply humanizing.
Together, Tom and Natalie bring complementary perspectives, humour, and a deep commitment to making assessment meaningful. Their partnership in Assess THAT and at the Canadian Assessment Centre reflects a shared belief that when educators improve how they assess, they unlock the full potential of every learner.
Tom and Natalie are also the authors of Rehumanizing Assessment: Gathering Evidence of Learning Through Storytelling, a book that challenges traditional grading systems and shows how assessment can honour student voice and identity.
Why Listen?Whether you’re a classroom teacher, school leader, or policy maker, Assess THAT with Tom & Nat will challenge your assumptions, equip you with actionable strategies, and inspire you to see assessment as the most powerful driver of student success.
Episodes
Mentioned books

Feb 24, 2025 • 36min
BONUS [TSP Classic] - Gholdy Muhammad (July 2022)
In this Tom Schimmer Podcast classic, Tom is joined by Gholdy Muhammad to discuss her book, "Cultivating Genius, an Equity Framework for Culturally and Historically Responsive Literacy."
Gholdy on X: @GholdyM
Gholdy on Instagram: @gholdym
PROFESSIONAL LEARNING EVENTS
MAR. 5-6 (Tom) GFIO 2-Day Workshop
San Antonio, TX
MAR. 24-25 (Tom) SBLA 2-Day
New Orleans, LA
APR. 5-6 (Tom & Nat) NESA Learning Futures Summit
Athens, Greece
June 25-27 (Tom & Nat) ST Assessment Collaborative Institue
Madison, WI
NEW BOOK
Rehumanizing Assessment through Story
CONNECT WITH TOM & NATALIE
Podcast on X
Tom on X
Natalie on X
Podcast on IG
Tom on IG
Natalie on IG
Email: assessthat24@gmail.com

8 snips
Feb 10, 2025 • 50min
9 - 3 Year Checklist for Implementing Standards-Based Grading
Discover a practical three-year roadmap for implementing standards-based grading tailored to your educational context. Learn about the crucial difference between proficiency and frequency scales in assessments. Explore fascinating cultural contrasts from their travels, emphasizing collaboration and learning among educators. Delve into the urgency needed in restructuring grading practices while encouraging patience and inclusivity among staff. Get insights on balancing academic and behavioral assessments for a fairer evaluation system.

Jan 27, 2025 • 34min
8 - The Secrets to Self-Assessment
Discover the transformative power of self-assessment in the classroom! The hosts reveal why it's essential for student empowerment and share strategies to navigate early implementation challenges. Learn about innovative methods like using exemplars and tools such as chat GPT to enrich student understanding. Hear how portfolios and data notebooks can drive meaningful reflection and engagement. Get ready to cultivate a culture of growth, as you help students take ownership of their learning journey!

Dec 2, 2024 • 39min
7 - The Grading Trap!
In this episode, Tom and Natalie discuss the "Grading Trap," which inadvertently occurs when traditional grading practices - things like zeros for missing work, late penalties, and mixing behavior with academic performance - end up working against learning instead of supporting it. The "Grading Trap" can inadvertently sabotage great teaching.
Tom and Natalie close the episode with ways that teachers can recognize the "red flags" of the "Grading Trap" and how they can get themselves out of it.
PROFESSIONAL LEARNING EVENTS
JAN. 24-25 (Tom) NESA Educators Training Institute
Abu Dhabi, U.A.E.
FEB. 6-7 (Natalie) GFIO 2-Day Workshop
Orlando, FL.
FEB 19 (Tom) PLC Summit KEYNOTE
Phoenix, AZ
MAR. 5-6 (Tom) GFIO 2-Day Workshop
San Antonio, TX
MAR. 24-25 (Tom) SBLA 2-Day
New Orleans, LA
APR. 5-6 (Tom & Nat) NESA Learning Futures Summit
Athens, Greece
June 25-27 (Tom & Nat) ST Assessment Collaborative Institue
Madison, WI
RECENT BOOKS:
"Redefining Student Accountability"
"Concise Answers to FAQs about Assessment & Grading"
"Jackpot: Nurturing Student Investment through Assessment"
CONNECT WITH TOM & NATALIE
Podcast on X
Tom on X
Natalie on X
Podcast on IG
Tom on IG
Natalie on IG
Email: assessthat24@gmail.com

Nov 18, 2024 • 34min
6 - Three Quick Assessment Wins
In this episode, Tom and Natalie discuss three quick assessment wins. Each "win" falls within a specific aspect of assessment.
Formative: Engineer conversations
Summative: Reorganize the gradebook.
Student Agency: Feedback through consent
PROFESSIONAL LEARNING EVENTS
JAN. 24-25 (Tom) NESA Educators Training Institute
Abu Dhabi, U.A.E.
FEB. 6-7 (Natalie) GFIO 2-Day Workshop
Orlando, FL.
FEB 19 (Tom) PLC Summit KEYNOTE
Phoenix, AZ
MAR. 5-6 (Tom) GFIO 2-Day Workshop
San Antonio, TX
MAR. 24-25 (Tom) SBLA 2-Day
New Orleans, LA
APR. 5-6 (Tom & Nat) NESA Learning Futures Summit
Athens, Greece
June 25-27 (Tom & Nat) ST Assessment Collaborative Institue
Madison, WI
RECENT BOOKS:
"Redefining Student Accountability"
"Concise Answers to FAQs about Assessment & Grading"
"Jackpot: Nurturing Student Investment through Assessment"
CONNECT WITH TOM & NATALIE
Podcast on X
Tom on X
Natalie on X
Podcast on IG
Tom on IG
Natalie on IG
Email: assessthat24@gmail.com

6 snips
Nov 4, 2024 • 51min
5 - The Anatomy of a Good Rubric
Discover the secrets behind crafting effective rubrics that balance art and science. The discussion dives into different types of rubrics—analytic, holistic, and single-point—and their unique benefits. Find out why task neutrality matters, allowing criteria to apply broadly across assignments. Gain insights into providing feedback that enhances long-term learning, while also exploring the evolving role of rubrics in education. Hear humorous travel tales alongside inspiring educational discussions that promote global collaboration.

Oct 21, 2024 • 44min
4 - Are Common Assessments Worth It?
In this episode, Tom and Natalie ask, "Are Common Assessments Worth It?" Spoiler alert: they are, as long as certain fundamentals and conditions are adhered to. In particular, when common assessments are used formatively they can be a powerful process for enhanced learning for students and teachers!
UPCOMING PROFESSIONAL LEARNING
Nov. 3-5: Aurora Institute Symposium
New Orleans, LA
RECENT BOOKS:
"Redefining Student Accountability"
"Concise Answers to FAQs about Assessment & Grading"
"Jackpot: Nurturing Student Investment through Assessment"
CONNECT WITH TOM & NATALIE
Podcast on X
Tom on X
Natalie on X
Podcast on IG
Tom on IG
Natalie on IG
Email: assessthat24@gmail.com

Oct 7, 2024 • 41min
3 - Feedback - Simple & Complex
In this episode, Tom and Natalie explore the topic of feedback. They discuss it as both simple and complex. It's simple because there is unanimous agreement in academia about the role feedback plays in increasing student learning. It's complex because there are many contributing factors that lead to feedback potentially being ineffective.
In the end, Tom & Nat leave you with six guidelines for effective feedback.
FEEDBACK LESSONS
Lesson 1 - What is feedback?
https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1Zj5UPoNEIJK3x_i6dxGC3bjMFmaYiQSo/copy
Lesson 2 - How can I ask for and give feedback?
https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1ISI4f0rarjXpitgc9Ab4hkNbrK127HJN/copy
UPCOMING PROFESSIONAL LEARNING
Oct. 17-19: NESA Fall Leadership Conference (Tom)
Dubai, U.A.E.
Nov. 3-5: Aurora Institute Symposium
New Orleans, LA
RECENT BOOKS:
"Redefining Student Accountability"
"Concise Answers to FAQs about Assessment & Grading"
"Jackpot: Nurturing Student Investment through Assessment"
CONNECT WITH TOM & NATALIE
Podcast on X
Tom on X
Natalie on X
Podcast on IG
Tom on IG
Natalie on IG
Email: assessthat24@gmail.com

Sep 23, 2024 • 45min
2 - Quieting the Grading Noise
In this episode of Assess THAT, Tom and Nat discuss how educators can quiet the grading noise. Whether it be the traditional graders on one side or the undgraders on the other, many educators can find themselves feeling uncertain about how to respond.
While the extreme positions often take center stage, especially online, it is the balanced positions that are more thoughtful, grounded, and helpful for those trying to navigate grading reform.
UPCOMING PROFESSIONAL LEARNING
Sep. 23-24: GFIO 2-Day (Tom)
Madison, WI
Sep. 25-26: SBLA 2-Day (Tom)
Madison, WI
Sep. 30-Oct. 1: GFIO 2-Day (Natalie)
Sacramento, CA
Oct. 17-19: NESA Fall Leadership Conference (Tom)
Dubai, U.A.E.
Nov. 3-5: Aurora Institute Symposium
New Orleans, LA
RECENT BOOKS:
"Redefining Student Accountability"
"Concise Answers to FAQs about Assessment & Grading"
"Jackpot: Nurturing Student Investment through Assessment"
CONNECT WITH TOM & NATALIE
Podcast on X
Tom on X
Natalie on X
Podcast on IG
Tom on IG
Natalie on IG
Email: assessthat24@gmail.com

Sep 9, 2024 • 34min
1 - Five Reasons we're still "doing" Assessment
In this first episode of Assess THAT, Tom & Nat discuss the five reasons assessment must still be an essential part of every educator's professional learning plan.
UPCOMING PROFESSIONAL LEARNING
Sep. 23-24: GFIO 2-Day (Tom)
Madison, WI
Sep. 25-26: SBLA 2-Day (Tom)
Madison, WI
Sep. 30-Oct. 1: GFIO 2-Day (Natalie)
Sacramento, CA
Oct. 17-19: NESA Fall Leadership Conference (Tom)
Dubai, U.A.E.
Nov. 3-5: Aurora Institute Symposium
New Orleans, LA
RECENT BOOKS:
"Redefining Student Accountability"
"Concise Answers to FAQs about Assessment & Grading"
"Jackpot: Nurturing Student Investment through Assessment"
CONNECT WITH TOM & NATALIE
Podcast on X
Tom on X
Natalie on X
Podcast on IG
Tom on IG
Natalie on IG
Email: assessthat24@gmail.com