Critics at Large | The New Yorker

The writer Carl Sandburg, in his 1926 biography of Abraham Lincoln, made a provocative claim—that the President’s relationship with the Kentucky state representative Joshua Speed held “streaks of lavender.” The insinuation fuelled a debate that has continued ever since: Was Lincoln gay? On this episode of Critics at Large, Vinson Cunningham, Naomi Fry, and Alexandra Schwartz discuss a new documentary that tries to settle the question. “Lover of Men: The Untold History of Abraham Lincoln” is part of a growing body of work that looks at the past through the lens of identity—a process that can reveal hidden truths or involve a deliberate departure from the facts. The hosts consider other distinctly modern takes on U.S. history, including the farcical Broadway sensation “Oh, Mary!,” which depicts Mary Todd Lincoln as a failed cabaret star and her husband as a neurotic closet case, and Lin-Manuel Miranda’s smash hit “Hamilton,” which reimagines the Founding Fathers as people of color. In the end, the way we locate ourselves in the past is inextricable from the culture wars of today. “It is a political necessity for every generation to be, like, No, this is what the past was like,” Cunningham says. “It points to a struggle that we’re having right now to redefine, What is America?” Read, watch, and listen with the critics:“Lover of Men: The Untold History of Abraham Lincoln” (2024)“Abraham Lincoln: The Prairie Years & The War Years,” by Carl SandburgCole Escola’s “Oh, Mary!”Lin-Manuel Miranda’s “Hamilton”“The Celluloid Closet” (1995)“Hidden Figures” (2016)“I’m Coming Out,” by Diana RossNew episodes drop every Thursday. Follow Critics at Large wherever you get your podcasts.   Learn about your ad choices: dovetail.prx.org/ad-choices

The podcast delves into the rising phenomenon of the 'trad wife' trend, showcasing influencers like Nara Smith and Hannah Neeleman, who embrace traditional domesticity while captivating millions online. It critiques the tensions between modern femininity and these age-old roles, considering choices women make in light of societal pressures and economic realities. The hosts also explore the Hulu series featuring Mormon wives, raising questions about empowerment and authenticity in an era where personal choices may not be as free as they seem.

The conversation dives into the mainstream acceptance of tarot and astrology, once considered 'woo-woo' but now part of our daily lives. Insights reveal how technology like astrology apps reflects our search for security in uncertain times. Personal anecdotes highlight the emotional connection to tarot during life transitions, such as loss and new beginnings. The discussion also explores the role of spirituality in relationships and how these mystical practices provide community support amidst societal pressures. A tarot reading adds a personal touch to the dialogue.

Nick Paumgarten, a staff writer at The New Yorker, joins to dive into the tantalizing mythology surrounding Las Vegas. They explore how the city meticulously crafted its identity as an entertainment mecca and its portrayal in culture, from Hunter S. Thompson's infamous work to modern-day residencies. The discussion touches on the paradox of escapism versus reality, the challenges artists face in such a commercialized space, and the city’s evolving role as a hub of artistic innovation. Tune in for a compelling reflection on the complexities of this iconic destination.

Charli XCX, a pop sensation whose album electrified a presidential campaign, teams up with the rising star Chappell Roan. They discuss the harsh realities of the pop music world, where success can be fleeting and fans dictate trends. Insights into Charli’s mainstream flirtation and Chappell's meteoric rise highlight the genre's cutthroat nature. The duo also reflects on the cultural impact of songs like ‘Espresso’ and the challenges faced by artists like Katy Perry. Their conversation navigates the evolving landscape of pop culture and the unique connections artists have with their fans.

Dive into the fascinating world of Tom Ripley, the quintessential antihero who steals more than just identities. The hosts explore the seductive nature of aspiration and class envy evident in Patricia Highsmith's work and its adaptations. They reflect on how social media mirrors Ripley's obsession with the glamorous lives of others. With a mix of humor and analysis, they dissect the psychology behind Ripley’s character and discuss the evolving perceptions of antiheroes in contemporary culture.

Kamala Harris, a prominent political figure recently launching her presidential campaign, draws intriguing comparisons with Charli XCX, a British pop artist celebrated for her album 'BRAT'. They explore how memes and pop culture intertwine with political narratives, showcasing a surprising wave of optimism amidst a backdrop of global crises. Armando Iannucci's satirical insights on politics provide a humorous lens. The conversation navigates the balance between hope and despair in today's world, reflecting on how younger generations embrace humor to tackle complex emotions.

Vanity Fair's 'Dynasty' podcast guests discuss Harry and Meghan's Hollywood journey, financial deals, media scrutiny, challenges post-royal life, charitable work, and strained relationships with the Royal Family. They explore the couple's transition to celebrity status in California and speculate on their sustainability in the limelight.

Critics at Large dives into the revelation of Alice Munro's daughter's sexual abuse by her stepfather and Munro's decision to stay with him. The discussion explores the impact on Munro's legacy, the delicate balance of separating art from artists, and the nuances of dealing with controversial figures in light of the #MeToo movement.

Renowned nature documentary presenter David Attenborough traces the evolution of nature documentaries from 'Zoo Quest' to 'Mammals.' The genre now addresses climate change while showcasing successful conservation efforts. The podcast reflects on the impact of nature documentaries in inspiring environmental awareness and conservation efforts.