Luckpilled Chapter Three: Politics of Luck

7 snips

Dec 2, 2024

In this discussion, Sarah Tulien, executive director of the Creator Accountability Network, sheds light on the politics of luck and meritocracy. She critiques the illusion of meritocracy, highlighting how it perpetuates systemic inequalities. The idea of a 'technocratic lucktopia' is presented as a vision for a fairer society. They explore how societal structures impact opportunities, emphasizing the need for radical changes in educational equity. They also tackle the implications of emotional education in addressing social issues like incel culture.

Ask episode

AI Snips

Chapters

Books

Transcript

Episode notes

INSIGHT

Meritocracy Team

Meritocracy functions like a team, with the Just World Illusion as the veteran.
Free will acts as the goalie, meritocracy as the power forward, scoring against other positions.

INSIGHT

Meritocracy's Roots

Modern meritocracy is a secularized Protestant work ethic, rewarding hard work and success.
The conservative work ethic dominates, assuming inequality and social mobility are necessary.

INSIGHT

Meritocracy's False Promises

Meritocracy claims to be about merit and social mobility but doesn't deliver.
Inherited wealth buys merit through better education and connections, creating dynasties.

Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode

Get the app

On liberty

John Stuart Mill

Published in 1859, 'On Liberty' is a seminal work by John Stuart Mill that argues for the protection of individual freedoms from the tyranny of the majority and government interference. Mill uses utilitarian philosophy to justify the value of liberty, emphasizing the importance of freedom of thought, discussion, and action. He introduces the 'harm principle,' which states that individuals should only be restrained from acting when their conduct may harm others. The essay is structured into five chapters, each addressing different aspects of liberty, including the liberty of thought and discussion, individual liberty, the limits of authority, and practical applications of his theories. Mill argues that protecting individual liberties is essential for societal progress and the avoidance of social stagnation[2][3][5].

A Psalm for the Wild-Built

Becky Chambers

A Psalm for the Wild-Built is the first book in the Monk & Robot series by Becky Chambers. The story takes place in a utopian future after the end of the Factory Age, where robots have gained consciousness and chosen to live in the wilderness. The novella follows Sibling Dex, a tea monk, and Mosscap, a sentient robot, as they journey to an abandoned hermitage. Along the way, they engage in philosophical discussions about human needs, purpose, and fulfillment. The book is characterized by its hopeful and optimistic tone, exploring themes of human nature, spirituality, and the importance of understanding and respecting each other's choices and agency[1][3][4].

Hijacked

Elizabeth Anderson

Elizabeth Anderson's "Hijacked" delves into the complexities of meritocracy and its impact on social justice. Anderson meticulously dissects the historical and philosophical underpinnings of meritocratic ideals, revealing their inherent contradictions and unintended consequences. She challenges the prevailing notion of individual deservingness, arguing that societal structures and historical inequalities significantly shape individual outcomes. The book offers a compelling critique of the dominant narrative surrounding meritocracy, exposing its role in perpetuating injustice and inequality. Anderson's work provides a framework for understanding how meritocratic systems often fail to deliver on their promises of fairness and efficiency.