Sarah Tuleen, Executive Director of the Creator Accountability Network, brings her K-12 education expertise to a lively discussion about the 'pedagogy of luck.' They explore how traditional education often perpetuates oppression and suggest a transformative approach with luck-pilling. The conversation delves into the complexities of educational philosophies, advocating for intrinsic motivation and empathy. Tuleen emphasizes the integration of mindfulness and social justice, promoting compassion and resilience in the classroom while challenging conventional beliefs about success and privilege.
The old pedagogy of luck emphasizes individual effort while neglecting contextual factors, contributing to negative educational dynamics.
Rethinking the growth mindset in light of luck pilling can create a supportive learning environment and reduce adversarial teacher-student relationships.
Teaching students about the role of luck can foster empathy and deeper understanding of social dynamics in their experiences.
Integrating mindfulness practices into education enhances emotional well-being and aids students in navigating the complexities of success and luck.
Deep dives
The Issue of Pedagogy in Education
Current educational practices often reinforce the old pedagogy of luck, which places excessive emphasis on effort and individual agency while downplaying the role of contextual factors like luck. Students internalize these meritocratic beliefs, mistakenly believing that success is predominantly due to hard work, even when data suggests otherwise. This entrenched mindset creates a tragedy of the educational commons, where both students and teachers are caught in a cycle of competition instead of collaboration in learning. To combat this, there is a need to critically assess and transform our educational approach to cultivate a more comprehensive understanding of success that includes the impacts of luck.
Growth Mindset and Its Limitations
The growth mindset approach, which emphasizes personal development through effort and resilience, while beneficial, can also lead to misconceptions about the role of luck in achievement. This perspective can result in students viewing their experiences solely through a lens of personal effort, oversimplifying the complex interplay of external factors. This skewed understanding can breed an environment where students see teachers as obstacles rather than allies in their learning journey, creating unnecessary stress and adversarial dynamics. Reevaluating the growth mindset approach in light of luck pilling allows for a more nuanced and supportive educational environment.
The Importance of Luck Awareness
Teaching students the concept of luck is crucial in promoting their awareness of the pervasive role it plays in life, influencing both successes and failures. By helping students recognize how much of their circumstances are shaped by factors beyond their control, educators can foster empathy and understanding towards themselves and others. This process, termed 'luck pilling', involves making increasingly complex discussions about personal and systemic injustices more accessible. It equips students to contextualize their experiences along with those of their peers, nurturing a deeper understanding of social dynamics.
Mindfulness and Education
Integrating mindfulness practices into education aligns well with the principles of luck pilling, helping students cultivate present-centered, non-judgmental awareness. Mindfulness exercises, such as non-judgmental introspection and focused attention on present experiences, can aid students in recognizing their emotions without harsh self-judgment. This practice can mitigate anxiety and promote resilience, enhancing overall emotional well-being. By fostering a mindful approach to learning, educators can empower students to navigate academic challenges with a clearer perspective on effort, success, and the influence of luck.
Transforming Grading Practices
The current grading system often prioritizes credentials over actual learning, leading to detrimental patterns of behavior among students and teachers alike. Emphasizing grades can shift focus from genuine understanding to mere performance, creating a cutthroat environment that diminishes intrinsic motivation and curiosity. A shift toward ungrading, where assessment is more qualitative and formative, encourages deeper learning experiences that honor individual progress rather than merely quantitative outputs. By adopting ungrading strategies, educators can create more equitable learning experiences that better reflect the complexities of student development.
Engaging with Social Justice Pedagogy
Incorporating social justice principles in education requires a thoughtful balance between addressing systemic issues and cultivating individual awareness of privilege and luck. This approach invites critical conversations about marginalization and identity, fostering a classroom environment that is inclusive and reflective of diverse experiences. By examining concepts of luck alongside privilege, educators can provide students with a framework for understanding societal inequalities without fostering defensiveness or disengagement. This engagement is vital for preparing students to be active, empathetic participants in creating a more just society.
Future Research Directions
Further research is essential to evaluate the impacts of luck pilling in educational contexts, focusing on both positive outcomes like enhanced learning experiences and potential pitfalls such as increases in nihilism or feelings of helplessness. Studies should validate whether implementing luck-awareness practices contributes to students’ mental health and overall engagement in learning. Investigating the longitudinal effects of shifting pedagogical approaches on student agency and success could pave the way for transformative educational practices. These insights would ultimately support a more equitable and effective educational framework that can enrich student experiences across various learning environments.
Episode five of our luckpilled series! We discuss the final chapter of my dissertation on pedagogy of luck. We work through the old pedagogy of luck and how it crashes the educational commons, before discussing how to do luckpilling generally and how to integrate it with three other progressive pedagogies: Mindfulness, social-emotional learning, and critical social justice pedagogy.
If you enjoy the show, please Like and Review us on your pod app, especially iTunes. It really helps!
This show is CAN credentialed, which means you can report instances of harassment, abuse, or other harm on their hotline at (617) 249-4255, or on their website at creatoraccountabilitynetwork.org.
Next Episode: Toby Buckle and the 2024 presidential election
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
