The Natty Or Not Roundtable Ft. Natural Hypertrophy, Geoffrey Verity Schofield, Dave Maconi
Feb 2, 2024
auto_awesome
Natural Hypertrophy, Geoffrey Verity Schofield, and Dave Maconi dive into the impact of the 'noble natty movement' on fitness culture and explore the ethical dilemmas surrounding steroid use. They debate the justification of performance enhancers and discuss the psychological impacts of being natural versus enhanced. The trio weighs in on the responsibilities of influencers to promote honesty and transparency in their journeys, while also critiquing the entertainment value of 'Natty or Not' content. Their banter is both enlightening and engaging!
The noble natty movement fosters a community that values natural bodybuilding while addressing potential elitism and promoting balanced conversations about enhancement choices.
The discussion critically examines the long-term health risks associated with PED use, emphasizing the importance of enjoying the natural journey of fitness over quick gains.
Ethics surrounding transparency in steroid use among fitness influencers highlight the importance of sharing honest experiences to provide realistic perspectives and discourage unhealthy comparisons.
Deep dives
Overview of the Noble Natty Movement
The noble natty movement is discussed as a largely positive phenomenon within the fitness community, wherein individuals take pride in remaining natural and not using performance-enhancing drugs. This movement instills a sense of identity among its supporters, promoting health and conscious choices regarding fitness. While some participants adopt a playful or ironic tone when calling themselves 'noble natty warriors,' it helps to build a healthy community focused on natural bodybuilding. The discussion also reflects on how the movement can sometimes foster unintentional elitism or shaming towards those who choose to use enhancement substances, emphasizing the need for a balanced perspective.
Impacts of Performance Enhancers
The potential downsides of performance-enhancing drugs (PEDs) are critically examined, highlighting the idea that many users might face long-term health consequences or dissatisfaction with their bodies after ceasing use. Some argue that the quick gains afforded by PEDs could overshadow the enjoyment and satisfaction that come from natural progression. The experience of enhanced lifters often differs from that of natural bodybuilders, as those on steroids may struggle to maintain their peak muscle size and strength over time. There is concern that early use of PEDs may undermine personal growth in both physical and mental aspects of training.
Ethics of Sharing Steroid Use
The ethics surrounding the disclosure of steroid use among fitness influencers are contemplated, particularly focusing on whether such individuals should come clean about their enhancement choices. The argument posits that those who profit from their physiques and advocate for specific training regimes have a responsibility to share their honest experiences with steroids to avoid misleading their audiences. Transparency is deemed important, as it provides newcomers with realistic perspectives on bodybuilding and discourages unhealthy comparisons. However, there is recognition that the consequences of being open about steroid use can vary significantly depending on the influencer's reputation and the nature of their content.
Stigmatization and Support for Natty Community
The discussion delves into the stigmatization surrounding steroid users, contrasting it with the support often found within the natural bodybuilding community. There is a call for the natty community to advocate against reckless steroid use while still promoting understanding and respect for personal choices. Engaging in constructive conversations rather than provocative attacks against those using PEDs is encouraged, as incendiary remarks can alienate potential allies and encourage division. Those who have achieved natural success are emphasized as credible sources of inspiration, reinforcing that a supportive narrative could lead to better personal choices.
Navigating the Gray Areas of Supplementation
As the conversation progresses, the complexities of using and promoting various supplements come to light, indicating a spectrum where some substances might offer legitimate benefits while others lean toward unhealthy practices. The discussion highlights the need for discernment among users regarding what information they consume and who they trust as sources. Users are encouraged to be aware of the nuances between naturally achieved physiques versus those enhanced by chemicals, emphasizing the importance of evidence-based practices. This reflective approach is intended to provide clarity amid the myriad of competing narratives around supplementation and personal fitness.
Consequences of Ignoring Health Risks
The conversation touches on the significant health risks associated with steroid use, highlighting cases where individuals have suffered severe consequences. This conversation aims to raise awareness of the dangers of taking PEDs without comprehending the full scope of potential pitfalls. The comparison is drawn between risking life and health by swimming in shark-infested waters versus the thrill of enhanced performance from drugs. Such analogies serve to underscore the critical notion that while quick gains can be enticing, the long-term repercussions of steroid use can be devastating and are important to consider in a responsible fitness journey.
Natural Hypertrophy, Geoffrey Verity Schofield, Dave and me (ssd abel) discuss what the noble natty movement has done to the fitness industry, and other topics that pertain to the topic of being enhanced vs staying natural.
0:00 - intro
1:19 - what does the noble natty movement mean?
8:26 - using steroids is always bad and never justifiable?
13:43 - tangient on super smash bros
14:50 - for whom is gear justifiable, continued
19:15 - NH weighs in on this too
26:50 - would you use gear if there were guaranteed no side effects?
35:18 - are natty or nots a net positive and are they ethical
53:36 - good genetics vs being enhanced
1:11:15 - do you have to come clean if you're using?
1:27:09 - is bashing on gear users discouraging honesty
1:34:40 - where can we find you?
Abel's Coaching and consultations:
https://ssdabel.com
insta: @abelfitstuff
Natural Hypertrophy YouTube channel:
https://www.youtube.com/@UCG-3rEW4IrDNa7-9iGByc2A
Geoff YouTube channel:
https://www.youtube.com/@UCObA5o3mcc1felIMAv6cukw
Geoff's Website:
https://www.verityfit.com/
Dave's Youtube:
https://www.youtube.com/@UCW-PI9YMJ6SXPiqXy2FYfLg
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode