Debating Refeeds and challenging Menno ft. Dave Maconi
Sep 9, 2020
auto_awesome
Debating the benefits of refeeds and diet breaks with Dave Maconi after previous discussions with Menno Henselmans. Skepticism vs. advocacy, anecdotes shared, adherence challenges, bodybuilders case studies, future research expectations. Protein sparing modified fasts, optimizing for gains, changing opinions, hardships of dieting mindset. Website, email, group links shared.
Refeeds and diet breaks optimize dieting strategies by balancing metabolism and muscle retention.
Diet breaks enhance adherence and reduce mental strain, supporting sustainable weight loss progress.
Consider individual tolerance and preferences when choosing between alternate day fasting and refeeds for effective calorie cycling.
Deep dives
The Role of Refeeds and Diabrakes in Dieting
Refeeds and diabrakes play a significant role in optimizing dieting strategies. While some view refeeds as beneficial for boosting metabolism and muscle retention, others question their impact. The discussion highlights the importance of timing and duration of refeeds to potentially enhance fat loss and metabolic adaptations. Individuals' experiences and preferences may influence the effectiveness of refeeds in achieving long-term dieting success.
Diet Breaks: A Psychological and Physiological Balancing Act
Diet breaks offer a balance between psychological and physiological aspects of dieting. Slowing down the rate of weight loss through diet breaks can improve adherence and reduce mental strain associated with prolonged deficits. The integration of longer diet breaks into a weight loss plan may provide benefits in reversing metabolic adaptations and supporting sustainable weight loss progress.
Alternate Day Fasting vs. Refeeds: A Comparison
The discussion of alternate day fasting versus refeeds highlights contrasting approaches to calorie cycling. While alternate day fasting concentrates deficits on specific days, refeeds focus on intermittent higher calorie days within a lower calorie regimen. The efficacy of each method may vary based on individual tolerance to deficit patterns and preferences for sustainable dietary practices.
Challenges in Research and Anecdotal Evidence
Navigating the complexities of research findings and anecdotal evidence poses challenges in determining the optimal dieting strategies. Understanding the limitations of studies and considering individual experiences are essential in evaluating the effectiveness of refeeds, diet breaks, and alternate day fasting. A comprehensive approach incorporating both empirical data and personal insights is crucial in shaping evidence-based dietary recommendations.
Digesting Diet Strategies and Caloric Cycling
The podcast delves into various diet strategies, including protein intake matching calorie numbers, protein-spare modified fasts, and carb cycling. It discusses implementing 24-hour fasts and alternating higher and lower calorie days based on workouts. The speaker emphasizes the importance of calorie distribution around workouts for optimal utilization and potential benefits of higher calories during that period.
Navigating Psychological Aspects of Dieting
The episode explores the psychology of dieting, discussing the impact of hunger, disrupted sleep, and mental fatigue during prolonged calorie deficits. It touches on the challenges of psychological turmoil associated with dieting, including the mental struggle at night and the cyclical effects of poor sleep and increased caffeine consumption. The conversation highlights the importance of managing psychological aspects of dieting and the potential impact on adherence and overall well-being.
After my recent interview with Menno Henselmans on refeeds and diet breaks, we dissect the same topic with Dave Maconi. He has been generally a proponent of refeeds and diet breaks, while personally I tended to lean towards the idea that refeeds and diet breaks are not as beneficial as many claim.
We attempt to have a civil argument here, which only occasionally turned hostile...in short, Dave attempted to destroy both Menno and me, while I tried my best to destroy him back.
Let's see how it turned out!
Time-Stamps:
0:00 - Some general talk about us getting older and becoming more fragile
7:44 - What influenced Dave in his thinking about refeeds
10:40 - My (Abel's) skepticism about refeeds
15:20 - Anecdotes on refeeds
20:00 - More of my skepticism on refeeds
23:26 - Refeeds, diet breaks and adherence
31:35 - Can you diet on higher calories with refeeds?
41:05 - The case studies of bodybuilders and why they are hard to evaluate
47:25 - What to expect from future research on diet breaks and refeeds
51:50 - Menno implementing protein sparing modified fasts for his lifters
1:01:10 - "Optimizing" things to get an extra 1% gains
1:05:05 - What would it take for us to change our opinion
1:08:20 - Menno's take on the hardships of dieting being in our heads
1:20:30 - Where can we found you?
Website/coaching:
http://abelssd.com/
you can reach out at:
abel.csabai at gmail.com
Facebook group:
https://www.facebook.com/groups/sustainableselfdevelopment/
Insta:
@SSD Abel
Dave's website:
https://drdavemaconi.com/
YouTube:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCW-PI9YMJ6SXPiqXy2FYfLg
Dave's insta:
@dave_maconi
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode