Dr. Gil Carvalho, a respected physician and research scientist, unpacks the complexities of canola oil's role in our health. He discusses the origins and composition of canola oil, the impact on blood lipids and cardiovascular health, its influence on weight loss and blood glucose control, and the controversy surrounding its inflammatory effects. Dr. Carvalho also examines various studies on canola oil, addressing concerns about oxidation, liver fat, and total mortality. Tune in for an insightful discussion that challenges common misconceptions about canola oil.
Canola oil consumption is generally safe and may have benefits for cardiovascular health, with lower LDL cholesterol and reduced triglycerides compared to other fats.
Comparisons between canola oil and nuts/seeds show no significant differences in cardiovascular risk factors.
Research on refined and unrefined canola oil indicates no specific risks to cardiovascular health.
Canola oil can be safely incorporated into a healthy diet without detrimental effects on cardiovascular health.
Deep dives
Canola oil and cardiovascular health
The available evidence from both randomized controlled trials and cohort studies suggests that consumption of canola oil is generally safe and may have benefits for cardiovascular health. In randomized controlled trials comparing canola oil with other fats, such as butter or high-saturated fat foods, canola oil was associated with lower LDL cholesterol, reduced apo-B levels, and decreased triglycerides. Meta-analyses of these trials found no significant differences in cardiovascular outcomes between canola oil and olive oil or sunflower seed oil. When examining long-term cohort studies, individuals who cooked with canola oil had a lower risk of cardiovascular mortality compared to those cooking with butter. The evidence from the large-scale Leon Diet Heart Study also showed a significant reduction in cardiovascular events and mortality with the consumption of a Mediterranean diet that included canola oil. While more research is needed to determine the specific mechanisms and optimal dosages, current evidence does not support the claims that canola oil is harmful to cardiovascular health.
Canola oil vs. nuts and seeds
Comparisons between canola oil and nuts or seeds have been limited, but available evidence suggests no significant differences in cardiovascular risk factors when replacing oils with nuts/seeds. One study compared a canola oil-enriched cereal with nuts, revealing no significant difference in lipid profiles, glucose metabolism, body weight, or blood pressure. There is, however, some heterogeneity in the research, and more studies are needed for a comprehensive understanding of the potential impact on cardiovascular health.
Refined and unrefined canola oil
Research comparing refined and unrefined canola oil specifically is scarce. However, studies using refined canola oil have shown either no significant differences or improvements in lipid profiles and cardiovascular health markers. As for unrefined canola oil, no head-to-head comparisons have been conducted. While further investigation is necessary, current evidence does not indicate any significant differences that would suggest refined or unrefined canola oil poses specific risks to cardiovascular health.
Limitations and need for further research
Although the available evidence provides valuable insights, there are still areas of uncertainty and gaps in research. Specific factors like optimal dosages, comparisons with other dietary patterns, and potential long-term effects require additional investigation. Nevertheless, the existing evidence overall indicates that canola oil can be safely incorporated into a healthy diet without detrimental effects on cardiovascular health.
Canola oil and its comparison with other diets
The podcast discusses the comparison of canola oil with other diets such as the Mediterranean diet and the French diet. The researchers point out that while canola oil showed impressive risk reduction, the comparison diets were not the cleanest. Despite this, canola oil still demonstrated no significant difference in glucose metabolism metrics compared to other oils, and even showed reductions in fasting glucose, insulin, and insulin resistance in certain trials.
Weight and body composition effects of canola oil
The podcast examines the impact of canola oil on weight and body composition. Results from randomized trials showed a small reduction in body weight when comparing canola oil to saturated fat, particularly among individuals with diabetes. However, there was no significant change in BMI, waist circumference, or body fat. These findings suggest that while there may be slight weight differences associated with canola oil, its impact on overall body composition is limited.
Canola oil's effects on inflammation and oxidation
The podcast delves into the research regarding canola oil's effects on inflammation and lipid oxidation. Multiple trials and meta-analyses showed no significant increase in inflammatory markers when comparing canola oil to other oils. In terms of lipid peroxidation, studies indicated that canola oil is resistant to oxidation when exposed to normal cooking temperatures. While some in-vitro assays suggested potential oxidation, they were found to be nonspecific and prone to artifacts.
Episode #288. Discover the truth about the canola oil debate with Dr Gil Carvalho. A respected physician and research scientist, Dr Carvalho unpacks the complexities of canola oil's role in our health. With no ties to industry, his unbiased perspective sheds light on how canola oil affects our bodies, its comparison to other oils, and the science behind the headlines. Tune in for a candid conversation that promises to enhance your understanding help you make informed dietary decisions.
Specifically, we discuss:
Introduction (00:00)
What Inspired the Canola Oil Video (01:58)
Defining Canola Oil: Origins and Composition (06:35)
The Most Common Claims About Canola Oil (12:13)
Research Methodology in Canola Oil Investigation (17:45)
The Significance of Human Data in Canola Oil Research (22:48)
Understanding Meta-analysis Studies and Epidemiological Approaches (26:37)
Assessing the Adequacy of Canola Oil Research (42:07)
Canola Oil's Impact on Blood Lipids and Cardiovascular Health (46:20)
Canola Oil vs. Nuts and Seeds for Weight Loss (50:36)
Canola Oil Consumption and the Risk of Heart Attack/Stroke (56:48)
Canola Oil and Blood Glucose Control (1:00:57)
Canola Oil's Influence on Body Weight (1:04:29)
Is Canola Oil Inflammatory? (1:08:54)
Examining the "Wash-IN-DIET Canola Oil" Study by Junker R and Kratz M (1:11:24)
Linoleic Acid Consumption and Total Mortality (1:23:10)
Reception of the Canola Oil Video within the NutritionMadeSimple Community (1:25:59)
Addressing Common Questions About Canola Oil (1:33:02)
Assessing Research Funding from the Canola Industry (1:37:19)
Making the Case for Canola Oil Toxicity (1:40:19)
Is Canola Oil Classified as an Ultra-Processed Food? (1:42:48)
Future Studies Required for a Comprehensive Understanding of Canola Oil and Human Health (1:46:50)
Conclusion (1:48:07)
You can learn more about Dr Gil Carvalho here, and connect with him on Twitter/X and Facebook. For straightforward, science-based nutrition information, visit his YouTube channel Nutrition Made Simple. You can also access his research publications for more.
Optimise your health with InsideTracker’s biomarker analysis. Get exclusive access to InsideTracker’s new ApoB test and a 20% discount on your first order at insidetracker.com/simon.
Enjoy, friends.
Simon
Want to support the show?
The best way to support the show is to use the products and services offered by our sponsors. To check them out, and enjoy great savings, visit theproof.com/friends. You can also show your support by leaving a review on the Apple Podcast app and/or sharing your favourite episodes with your friends and family.