Natural sugar alternatives like honey and maple syrup still contain fructose and glucose and have similar metabolic effects as table sugar.
Instead of solely focusing on the choice between natural sugar alternatives and table sugar, it is important to address hidden sugars in processed foods and consider the overall diet, fiber content, and how sugars are consumed within whole foods.
Deep dives
The popularity of natural sugar alternatives
Natural sugar alternatives like honey, maple syrup, stevia, and agave are widely used as substitutes for table sugar. Honey is the most popular spread in the UK, while maple syrup production in the US exceeds five million gallons annually. Stevia, derived from a sweet-tasting plant, is also gaining popularity. However, it's important to note that stevia products often contain other ingredients, such as the artificial sweetener erythritol.
The perception of natural sugar alternatives as healthier
Many people believe that natural sugar alternatives are healthier than table sugar due to their less processed nature and perceived naturalness. However, these alternatives, such as honey and maple syrup, still contain fructose and glucose and have similar metabolic effects in the body as table sugar. Some alternatives, like honey, may contain extra micronutrients, but in small amounts. Switching to natural sugar alternatives does not necessarily provide dramatically different health outcomes.
The importance of overall sugar consumption
Rather than focusing solely on the choice between natural sugar alternatives and table sugar, it is more crucial to address the hidden sugars in processed foods. Many individuals consume excessive amounts of sugar from hidden sources. The impact of sugar consumption on health depends on factors such as overall diet, fiber content, and how sugars are consumed within whole foods. Consuming sugars within whole foods, like fruits, with their fiber content can have different metabolic effects compared to added sugars.
Get science-based nutrition advice delivered straight to your inbox. https://bit.ly/46BPTYz
Are you trying to eat less sugar? If you are, you might have tried a natural sugar alternative.
Stevia, robinia honey, coconut sugar, agave… the list of these table sugar replacements seems to be growing day by day. But what even are these alternatives? Are they really natural? And do they offer us a healthier way of getting that sweet taste?
In today’s short episode of ZOE Science & Nutrition, Jonathan and Dr. Sarah ask: What are natural sugar alternatives, and are they healthier than table sugar?