Sunita Sah, an award-winning professor of organizational psychology and author of "Defy: The Power of No in a World That Demands Yes," sheds light on the complexities of defiance and compliance. She discusses how Milgram's experiment influenced her career, and the communal importance of speaking up for others. Sunita explains the five elements that define a genuine 'yes' and shares a touching story about her mother’s unexpected act of defiance that taught her hope, highlighting how aligning our actions with values can reduce stress and promote authenticity.
Dr. Sunita Sah highlights the moral dilemmas faced by individuals under authority pressure, revealing the complexities of obedience and personal responsibility.
The episode emphasizes the importance of introspection to align personal values with actions, particularly when confronting societal expectations.
Sah introduces the idea of defiance as a skill that can be cultivated, encouraging listeners to articulate their discomfort in coercive situations.
The discussion underscores the ripple effect of individual defiance, suggesting that personal acts of courage can inspire collective action within communities.
Deep dives
The Importance of Defying the Norm
The podcast discusses the concept of defying societal expectations, emphasizing the significance of standing up for oneself, especially in environments that typically demand conformity. Dr. Sunita Saw highlights how many people find it challenging to voice their needs and beliefs when pressured by authority, underscoring the implications of failing to assert oneself. The episode notes that the societal pressures often lead individuals to prioritize compliance over personal values, which can result in feelings of resentment and frustration. Insights are shared about finding the courage to defy these norms, advocating for a balance between personal integrity and societal expectations.
Morality and Obedience
The discussion revisits the infamous Milgram experiments on obedience, which revealed startling statistics about people's willingness to follow authority figures even when it meant causing harm to others. Dr. Saw reflects on how these findings correlate with real-life incidents, such as those involving law enforcement, and the moral dilemmas faced by individuals under authority pressure. This exploration raises poignant questions about human nature, obedience, and personal responsibility, illuminating the internal conflict many individuals experience when faced with ethical dilemmas. The episode ultimately challenges listeners to consider how they might react in similar situations and to recognize the importance of moral courage.
Defiance as a Skill Set
Dr. Saw asserts that defiance is not merely about being rebellious but rather a skill that can be developed through practice and awareness. She encourages listeners to recognize their body's signals of discomfort when faced with coercive situations and to use those feelings as prompts for introspection and action. By outlining stages of defiance, Dr. Saw empowers individuals to articulate their feelings and ultimately choose how they respond to pressure. This thoughtful approach places the onus of action on the individual, reaffirming that defiance can be a proactive and positive force in various contexts.
Cultural Influences on Defiance
The podcast highlights how cultural and social influences play a significant role in shaping individuals' willingness to defy authority. Dr. Saw refers to the concept of 'insinuation anxiety,' where individuals fear that asserting their own opinions may question the competence or trustworthiness of others. This fear often stifles dissenting voices, particularly in environments like workplaces or academic settings. The episode notes the complexities of navigating such social dynamics, stressing the need for dialogue about defiance across cultures to foster a more equitable environment.
Personal Anecdotes and Real-World Application
Throughout the episode, Dr. Saw shares personal anecdotes and real-world examples that demonstrate the practical applications of her theories on defiance. These stories resonate with listeners, illustrating the tangible impact of asserting oneself in various scenarios, ranging from healthcare settings to law enforcement situations. By grounding her concepts in relatable experiences, she effectively demonstrates that the journey toward embracing one's values and expressing dissent can be fraught with challenges yet is ultimately rewarding. These narratives serve as inspiration for listeners to engage with their own challenges and foster personal growth.
Rethinking Our Values
A central theme in the episode revolves around the need for introspection and reevaluation of personal values amidst external pressures. Dr. Saw advocates for taking time to consider what one truly stands for and how that aligns with everyday actions. By asking probing questions about values, individuals can map out how they want to respond to situations that challenge their beliefs. This reflection not only nurtures personal growth but also guides individuals toward acting in a way that aligns with their authentic selves.
Personal Responsibility and Collective Action
The podcast emphasizes the relationship between personal responsibility and the broader social implications of defiance. Dr. Saw encourages listeners to recognize that asserting one's values can have ripple effects, prompting others in the community to also stand up for themselves. The conversation suggests that collective action begins with individual choices, highlighting the power of unity in creating an environment where dissent is valued and respected. This message positions defiance as not merely a personal act but a collective movement toward a more just society.
Practical Tools for Defiance
In the latter part of the episode, Dr. Saw offers practical tools designed to help individuals cultivate their defiance skills. She discusses techniques for recognizing and articulating discomfort during challenging interactions and sharing them with others. By doing so, individuals can strengthen their resolve and encourage a culture of open dialogue and respectful dissent. These tools serve as actionable steps for listeners to implement in their own lives, turning theoretical concepts of defiance into real opportunities for positive change.
Sunita Sah (Defy: The Power of No in a World That Demands Yes) is an author, award-winning, tenured professor at Cornell University, and expert in organizational psychology. Sunita joins the Armchair Expert to discuss living up to the Sanskrit meaning of her name, why Milgram’s electric shock experiment pushed her to pursue psychology, and how some of the wildest and offtrack people she knows are doctors. Sunita and Dax talk about how speaking up when you see something happening to someone else is a communal act, how Dax goes straight from tension to defiance, and whether defiance is evolutionarily maladaptive. Sunita explains the five elements that define a true yes, how we can reduce stress by clarifying and acting in alignment to our values, and tells the story of her mother’s defiance that surprised her and taught her hope.
Follow Armchair Expert on the Wondery App or wherever you get your podcasts. Watch new content on YouTube or listen to Armchair Expert early and ad-free by joining Wondery+ in the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts, or Spotify. Start your free trial by visiting wondery.com/links/armchair-expert-with-dax-shepard/ now.
