Rapid Response: How Barstool Sports’ ex-CEO cooks up attention, with Food52’s Erika Ayers Badan
Jul 30, 2024
auto_awesome
Erika Ayers Badan, former CEO of Barstool Sports and now leading Food52, shares her insights on navigating contrasting cultures in the media industry. She reveals the chaotic yet vibrant nature of Barstool versus the structured approach at Food52. Ayers Badan discusses the impact of public scrutiny on leadership and the importance of saying 'no' as a leader. With a focus on community building and adaptability, she emphasizes how the lessons from her past can reshape the food and lifestyle landscape.
Erika Ayers Badan emphasizes that the chaotic, community-driven model of Barstool Sports can revolutionize the food industry through authentic customer connections.
She underscores the necessity of leadership decisiveness, advocating for the importance of saying 'no' to maintain focus and clarity within organizations.
Deep dives
The Transition from Barstool to Food52
Erica Ayers-Badon describes her move from Barstool Sports to Food52 as an unconventional career pivot, reflecting on the stark differences between the two organizations. While Barstool thrived on wild creativity and controversy, Food52 embodies a more structured and community-focused ethos. Despite these differences, both companies share a core principle centered around community, marking Ayers-Badon’s desire to build authentic connections with customers. She highlights the rapid growth of Barstool, noting how revenues skyrocketed from $5 million to $300 million within a few years, showcasing her successful leadership during that chaotic period.
Community Building and Content Strategy
Ayers-Badon emphasizes the importance of community in both Barstool and Food52, but acknowledges that the execution differs due to the demographic and interests of their audiences. At Barstool, the young, male audience demanded edginess and humor, leading to constant experimentation and immediate reactions to current events. In contrast, Food52 caters to an audience that values expertise and reliability around home and food, suggesting a need for a different approach to engage them effectively. She is keen to explore how to mix humor with traditional culinary content to foster a more dynamic and interactive environment, urging the organization to adapt to emerging social trends.
Navigating Controversy and Corporate Culture
Ayers-Badon reflects on the criticisms surrounding Barstool, particularly regarding its perceived toxic masculinity, and how she aimed to create a professional and cohesive environment amidst the chaos. She noted that while Barstool drew headlines for controversies, it also fostered an unfiltered and honest culture that she found revitalizing compared to her experiences in larger corporations like Microsoft. This candid atmosphere encouraged her to prioritize building a strong foundation of values in Food52, seeking a more collaborative and diverse workplace. Recognizing the challenges of shifting public perception, she stresses the need for genuine engagement over mere crisis management.
Learning to Say No as a Business Leader
Ayers-Badon shares her insights on the importance of decisiveness in leadership, particularly the value of saying 'no' when necessary. Her experiences at Microsoft equipped her with the skills to navigate multiple demands, reinforcing that clear boundaries promote discipline within an organization. By prioritizing thoughtful decision-making, she believes leaders can focus their team's efforts more effectively and maintain a clear vision. This capacity to decline unaligned opportunities, according to her, reflects a deeper knowledge of what is required to advance the organization's goals.
Controversy, frat house culture, viral moments — when you hear ‘Barstool Sports,’ this may be what comes to mind. But former CEO Erika Ayers Badan is here to tell you that the business model that made Barstool into an online cultural juggernaut is replicable and poised to re-shape the food and lifestyle industry. Ayers Badan shares with Rapid Response why she decided to make a dramatic career pivot — taking over Food52 — and why running Barstool was like “a heart attack every day.” She also explores lessons around cultivating a community of fans, and why as a leader, “no” is often a better answer than “yes.”