Former journalist turned successful newsletter entrepreneur, Matt Brown, shares his journey of building and selling a paid newsletter. Topics include starting a newsletter as a business, leveraging earned media for growth, using a video game as a lead magnet, monetizing newsletters with different pricing options, audience turnover and monetization challenges, collecting and utilizing audience feedback for sponsorships, and the importance of original content to differentiate the newsletter.
Read more
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
The revenue for Extra Points primarily comes from premium subscriptions, with over 90% of the revenue generated through paid subscriptions.
Extra Points offers flexible pricing options, including individual paid subscriptions and bulk subscription packages, making it appealing to universities and organizations.
Extra Points is exploring additional monetization strategies beyond paid subscriptions, such as advertising, selling audience insights, and offering courses or consulting services.
Deep dives
Overview of Extra Points newsletter
Extra Points is a sports-focused newsletter that covers the off-the-field forces shaping college athletics. It publishes four times a week, with two free and two premium paywall articles. The content includes business stories like media rights negotiations and apparel contracts, as well as educational research and sports management. Extra Points caters to three main audiences: passionate American college sports fans, industry leaders and practitioners, and students studying sports management. The newsletter has close to 16,000 subscribers, with over 3,000 paying subscribers. While the revenue comes from a mix of ads and affiliate marketing, the majority, over 90%, is generated through premium subscriptions.
Revenue Streams and Team Packages
The revenue for Extra Points primarily comes from premium subscriptions, while ads and affiliate marketing contribute a smaller share. The newsletter offers individual paid subscriptions at $8 a month or $75 for the year. Additionally, Extra Points sells bulk subscription packages and has a product called D1 Classroom, specifically designed for universities. The team packages provide educational institutions with access to Extra Points and additional custom products. The pricing is flexible, offering discounts based on the number of subscribers, making it an attractive option for universities and organizations interested in providing the newsletter to their students or staff.
Monetization Strategies and Challenges
Extra Points is exploring additional monetization strategies beyond paid subscriptions. The team is considering options like advertising, selling audience insights, and offering courses or consulting services. However, finding the right approach within the distinct audience groups has proven challenging. While students and their future job market potential are valuable to reach, they may not be the target sponsors for the newsletter. Conventional sponsorship opportunities have been inconsistent, and aligning ad sales packages across different companies has been a hurdle. However, as Extra Points continues to grow its audience and expand its offerings, it aims to find more effective ways to monetize its engaged readership.
Creating an Unexpected Game
The podcast episode discusses the unexpected creation of a Python text adventure game called 'Athletic Director Simulator 3000'. The game was initially created as a simple and humorous demonstration of the host's coding skills but received unexpected positive feedback from industry professionals. This led to the game being developed into a more robust version with the help of a third-party contractor. The game allows players to navigate scenarios as a university athletic director, making decisions and managing resources. The game serves as a new way to engage and retain subscribers while also generating interest from potential classroom package customers.
Revenue Streams and Audience Insights
The podcast episode delves into the main revenue stream for the newsletter, which is paid subscriptions. The host discusses different pricing options, including annual and bulk subscriptions. They also mention occasional sales and targeted offers based on user engagement. Additionally, the host shares insights on audience demographics and conversion rates from free to paid subscribers. They express the importance of collecting feedback from the audience through surveys and exploring ways to leverage that data for potential brand partnerships and advertising. Despite being in a niche market, the challenges of attracting niche-specific advertisers are highlighted, emphasizing the need to find unique selling points and targeted opportunities for revenue growth.
Welcome back to another episode of the Send & Grow podcast. This week, SparkLoop cofounder Louis Nicholls sits down with Matt Brown of Extra Points, a paid newsletter for the college sports industry.
Matt was laid off from working at Vox during the pandemic. He started the Extra Points newsletter as a business experiment. And it's paid off. With 16k subscribers, including 3k paid, Matt's leveraged his experience, business savvy, and network to build & sell a newsletter in under 3 years. After selling to D1 Ticker, Matt's remained as head publishing for Extra Points.
In this episode, Louis & Matt discuss…
Starting a newsletter as a business
Matt's philosophy for free vs. paid content
How to leverage earned media for growth
Using a video game as a lead magnet for paid subscriptions