Making Sense with Sam Harris - Subscriber Content
Making Sense of Meditation
Episode guests
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
- Meditation can uncover automatic thinking patterns and reduce psychological suffering.
- Dependent origination in Buddhism mirrors operant conditioning, highlighting commonalities in shaping behaviors.
- Understanding addiction through neuroscience and meditation offers insights into human behavior and habit formation.
- The integration of science and spirituality in meditation enhances well-being and ethical considerations.
Deep dives
Understanding Reward-Based Learning and Addiction
Reward-based learning involves triggers, behaviors, and rewards to form habits. The brain lays down context-dependent memory for survival. Thoughts automaticity can reflect addiction with thoughts continually flowing despite meditation. Trying to force thoughts to stop can backfire, as seen in attempting to lose weight. Anticipation of reward can shift from receipt of reward, motivating behaviors.
Exploring Meditation and Addiction of Thinking
Addiction to thinking can be like an addiction to an anticipated reward. Meditation can uncover the automaticity of discursive thoughts. Judson Brewer shares his experience from meditation, showing how challenging it can be to control thoughts. Reward-based learning explains how behaviors are driven by the anticipation of reward rather than the behavior itself.
The Common Framework in Dependent Origination and Operant Conditioning
Dependent origination, central to Buddha's enlightenment, parallels operant conditioning, a behaviorist concept of reward-based learning. Both frameworks describe triggers, responses, and rewards shaping behavior. The Buddha's understanding predated modern discoveries of reward-based learning, highlighting the universality of this psychological process.
Bridging Neuroscience, Behavior, and Buddhist Concepts
The interconnection between neuroscience, behavior, and Buddhist teachings is evident in the commonalities of reward-based learning and dependent origination. Understanding addiction, meditation, and behavior change through these frameworks sheds light on the psychological processes underpinning human behavior and habits.
Meditation and Its Psychological Impact
The practice of meditation, as discussed in the podcast, aims to provide insights into the nature of thought processes and reduce psychological suffering by fostering non-attachment to thoughts. The podcast highlights that meditative practices focus on recognizing the present moment to overcome craving and avoid unnecessary suffering. Furthermore, through an intellectual lens, the pursuit of meditation is seen as a way to live a happier life by navigating and understanding the complexities of consciousness and thought processes.
Scientific Approach to Meditation and Spirituality
The integration of meditation and spirituality with a rigorous scientific mindset is explored in the podcast. It emphasizes the importance of reason in forming beliefs about the world and the utility of science in understanding human well-being. The discussion delves into the neurophysiological basis of meditation practices and the holistic approach of science in improving societal well-being. The dialogue underscores the alignment between scientific exploration and spiritual contemplation to enhance human flourishing and ethical considerations.
Duality of Science and Spiritual Wonder
The convergence of scientific inquiry and the boundless mysteries of existence is highlighted in the podcast. Despite scientific advancements, the fundamental enigma of consciousness remains, sparking awe and humility in individuals. The conversation stresses the coexistence of intellectual progress and the eternal mystery embedded within consciousness and perception. It concludes that the pursuit of understanding reality and enriching human experience is a journey marked by both scientific exploration and spiritual appreciation.
In this episode, we traverse a decade of Sam’s conversations on the topic of meditation.
We start with the very first recorded episode from the archives: a conversation with Sam’s meditation teacher and friend, Joseph Goldstein. Goldstein recalls how his thinking was unlocked—allowing him to fully realize the power of the practice—by the utterance of one single word.
We then hear from author Richard Lang as he guides us towards a strangely obvious insight that came to be known as “the headless way.” Next, philosopher and neuroscientist Thomas Metzinger employs his vast expertise in both neurobiology and meditation to show how our brains generate a model of the world and self, and how meditation can help us catch that process in the act.
Psychiatrist Judson Brewer then shifts the conversation to some very practical applications of mindfulness meditation, addressing the problem of addiction to things like food, smoking, or drugs by retraining the reward centers in our brains. Next, Daniel Goleman and Richard Davidson dig into the neuroscience of meditation and discuss how experienced meditators may actually be physically altering their brains.
We then listen in on Sam’s conversation with author Robert Wright, who defends the claim that “Buddhism is true.” Sam and Wright discuss the validity of this claim while ensuring they keep it separate from the political and moral behaviors of Buddhist nations and individuals.
We conclude with Sam delivering the answer to a question posed by the Belgian neuroscientist Steven Laureys. In doing so, Sam provides a comprehensive tour of his philosophies. He ties together his personal brand of moral analysis, his reverence for science and truth seeking, and his reasoning as to why he still meditates and why he proudly promotes the practice.
About the Series
Filmmaker Jay Shapiro has produced The Essential Sam Harris, a new series of audio documentaries exploring the major topics that Sam has focused on over the course of his career.
Each episode weaves together original analysis, critical perspective, and novel thought experiments with some of the most compelling exchanges from the Making Sense archive. Whether you are new to a particular topic, or think you have your mind made up about it, we think you’ll find this series fascinating.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
