Undercurrents

Ashley Frawley, a senior editor at Compact, dives into the implications of Justin Trudeau's resignation for Canada and the broader West. She discusses the political dynamics between Trudeau, Pierre Paulyev, and even Donald Trump, highlighting the challenges facing the Canadian political landscape. Frawley argues that both the left and right are stuck in identity politics, making it hard to defend true freedom. She also addresses the disorientation of the Canadian left amidst rising populism and societal shifts, questioning their strategy moving forward.

Batya Ungar-Sargon, an opinion editor at Newsweek and author known for her sharp political commentary, discusses the tensions between Elon Musk and the MAGA movement. She questions Musk's motivations behind addressing the UK's grooming gang scandal and how it distracts from critiques of immigration. The conversation dives into Musk's influence on conservative discourse and the misconceptions surrounding American labor. Lastly, Ungar-Sargon examines the shifting dynamics between Musk and Steve Bannon, exploring the future trajectory of MAGA.

In this engaging discussion, Charlie Peters, a prominent journalist from GB News, sheds light on the troubling grooming gang scandal in the UK. He shares insights on Parliament's rejection of a national inquiry, raising concerns about systemic failures and cover-ups. Peters emphasizes the urgent need for accountability and advocates for the voices of survivors, who reveal the psychological manipulation involved. The conversation challenges listeners to confront uncomfortable truths about exploitation and the societal factors at play.

Become a supporter of the show - just $1 for the first month: https://unherd.com/undercurrents/Sohrab Ahmari joins Emily to share his personal experience battling Meta’s factcheckers. After Mark Zuckerberg admitted Meta’s policies led to censorship, Ahmari argues the change is good but could mean continued collusion between oligarchs and partisans.  Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Matthew Mehan, Professor at Hillsdale College and expert in political philosophy, joins the discussion to explore the nuances of retribution in American politics. He delves into Trump's evolving stance on accountability, questioning whether his approach signals genuine justice or just a vendetta. They discuss the challenges of political perjury and the need for transparency, while emphasizing the importance of bipartisanship. The conversation critically balances the concepts of justice and retribution, urging a focus on integrity and unity in a fractured political landscape.

Jeremy Carl, former Deputy Assistant Secretary of the Interior and senior fellow at the Claremont Institute, dives deep into the contentious world of H-1B visas. He argues that the current program is detrimental to American labor and discusses Vivek Ramaswamy’s controversial stance, painting it as dangerously misguided. Carl reflects on the tech industry's influence over immigration policies and highlights the ethical and economic implications of temporary worker systems. His insights shed light on the complex intersection of politics, immigration, and American work culture.

A suspected terrorist attack in New Orleans reveals the FBI's chaotic response and institutional failures. Mistakes by law enforcement erode public trust, amplifying fear. The discussion highlights unsettling parallels between the New Orleans and Las Vegas incidents, including the use of rented vehicles by military veterans. These incidents raise questions about accountability, systemic changes needed to prevent future tragedies, and the potential repercussions for FBI leadership amid calls for reform.

Robby Soave, a seasoned journalist at Reason, dives into the transformative power of podcasts on modern media. He discusses the 'podcast election' of 2024 and its potential to permanently alter the landscape of journalism. Key themes include the tension between skepticism and misinformation, and how platforms like Substack give voice to independent journalists. Soave also critiques how political figures adapt their strategies to engage younger audiences while balancing traditional journalism with new forms of authentic communication. The conversation reveals crucial insights into the evolving media dynamics.

Christine Rosen, a Senior Fellow at the American Enterprise Institute and seasoned columnist, revisits the infamous Duke lacrosse case. She discusses how the false accusations against the players not only shaped media narratives but also triggered culture wars still felt today. The conversation delves into the repercussions for both accused and victims, accountability in feminism, and ideological missteps in media. Rosen also examines the interplay of contemporary feminism with movements like Me Too, highlighting tensions between traditional and modern values.

Michael Malice, an author known for his provocative takes and the host of "You're Welcome," joins to dive deep into American culture during Trump’s second term. He discusses how critics of Trump may have misjudged their influence, suggesting they 'overplayed their hand.' Malice explores the shifts in political identity and the impact of younger generations on discourse, particularly surrounding cancel culture. The conversation also sheds light on the evolving landscape of media and comedy in response to political polarization.