
Criminal
Criminal is the first of its kind. A show about people who’ve done wrong, been wronged, or gotten caught somewhere in the middle. Hosted by Phoebe Judge. Named a Best Podcast of 2023 by the New York Times. Part of the Vox Media Podcast Network.
Latest episodes

42 snips
Jul 11, 2025 • 51min
The Man Nobody Killed
In a deep dive into the vibrant East Village of the 1980s, the tragic story of Michael Stewart unfolds, exploring the artistic chaos and personal struggles that defined the era. The podcast highlights the unsettling moments surrounding police violence and the reluctance of bystanders to intervene. With a focus on the controversial autopsy that raised questions about accountability, listeners are taken through protests and the community's response to police brutality. The echoes of Stewart's case resonate through societal reflections on art and justice.

17 snips
Jul 4, 2025 • 36min
The Clearwater Monster
Jeff Signorini, son of the notorious Clearwater Monster, shares hilarious tales about his father’s pranks that sparked a local legend. Journalist Jeff Klinkenberg provides a vivid account of the town's wild reactions when gigantic, three-toed footprints appeared on the beach, igniting imaginations about a sea creature. The duo delves into the whimsical hoax behind the rumors, with anecdotes about Ivan Sanderson's captivating personality and the creative mischief that brought the community together in laughter.

13 snips
Jun 27, 2025 • 35min
Uncle Harold
Eric Konigsberg, author of *Blood Relation*, unpacks his shocking discovery that his uncle, Harold, was a mafia hitman. He shares the eerie voicemail from Harold that sparked his investigation. The conversation weaves through family pride tangled with a criminal legacy, the emotional turmoil of visits to maximum-security prison, and dark secrets of organized crime. Konigsberg dives into the chilling impacts of Harold’s actions on both his family and his victims' families, portraying a complex portrait of loyalty, trauma, and the powerful grip of a notorious past.

26 snips
Jun 20, 2025 • 50min
By Any Means Necessary
Traveling through Italy takes an unexpected turn when a woman finds her boyfriend's passport with a different name. Their budding romance faces turmoil deepened by the boyfriend's secret life as an undercover officer. The narrative explores themes of love, betrayal, and the emotional fallout of deceptive relationships. Insightful discussions reveal the ethical implications of undercover operations and the call for reforms in policing practices. Through humor and serious inquiry, complex emotions and the struggles of activism are brought to light.

22 snips
Jun 13, 2025 • 36min
The Guru
Shruti Swamy, a writer and former disciple of Swami Rama, shares her intriguing journey within a spiritual community steeped in mysticism. She discusses the complex dynamics of trust and the disillusionment faced when allegations against a revered leader arise. Shruti reveals the cultural identity struggles her immigrant family encountered and reflects on the impact of both devotion and betrayal. The conversation dives deep into the nuanced legacy of gurus, exploring themes of faith, manipulation, and the allure of a spiritual path.

9 snips
Jun 6, 2025 • 35min
Professor Quaalude
Peter Klopfer, a biologist and collaborator at Duke University, shares riveting tales from the captivating world of lemurs. He recounts the amusing escapades and care efforts at the Duke Lemur Center, emphasizing teamwork in research and conservation. The conversation takes a darker turn as they explore the bizarre transformation of John Buettner-Janusch, from a revered academic to a criminal embroiled in drug production. Klopfer reflects on the profound impacts of loss and resilience in academia, intertwining tragedy with unexpected narratives.

7 snips
May 30, 2025 • 24min
Thin Ice and Unusual Punishments
Discover the behind-the-scenes journey of true crime storytelling, filled with humor and heartfelt moments. Hear about a daring rescue on a frozen lake that showcases bravery. Delve into the eerie case of Teresita Basa, solved through dream insights. Explore unconventional judicial punishments, like a judge ordering a poacher to watch 'Bambi' monthly. The podcast also sheds light on unique sentencing practices that challenge traditional justice, sparking intriguing discussions about the legal system.

26 snips
May 23, 2025 • 34min
Action Park
Chris Gethard, a comedian from New Jersey, shares his wild experiences at Action Park, the infamous amusement park known for its dangerous attractions. Seth Porges, a documentary filmmaker, provides insights into Gene Mulvihill's audacious rise and the park's chaotic legacy. They delve into the risky innovations of ride designs that attracted thrill-seekers, and the alarming safety practices that resulted in numerous incidents. The discussion contrasts nostalgic memories of adventure with modern concerns about safety in amusement parks.

25 snips
May 16, 2025 • 38min
No Hint or Help
Richard Tedlow, a historian specializing in media, joins to unravel the captivating yet controversial world of 1950s quiz shows. He discusses the disastrous launch of 'Twenty One' and how producers resorted to manipulation to save it. Tedlow highlights the ethical dilemmas faced by contestants, specifically Charles Van Doren, whose fame was built on deception. The podcast dives into the subsequent Congressional investigation that transformed television, culminating in the birth of 'Jeopardy!', a show that restored trust in quiz entertainment.

54 snips
May 9, 2025 • 39min
False Positive
Shoshana Walter, a keen reporter at Reveal, teams up with Susan Horton, a mother whose life was turned upside down by a false positive opiate test after eating a poppy seed salad. They delve into the emotional chaos of Susan facing intervention from child welfare authorities just as she welcomed her newborn. The discussion highlights the chilling effects of medical misdiagnosis, the ongoing battle against wrongful accusations, and the desperate need for reform in drug testing practices. A compelling listen for anyone intrigued by the intersection of justice and family.