Criminal The Test
Feb 6, 2026
Mikita Brottman, author and cultural commentator, guides the narrative with concise analysis. She unpacks a mysterious disappearance at Lake Seminole, a mother's relentless search, and a tangled web of affairs, insurance and a chilling 'test' plan. The story follows investigations, arrests, trials and the book that keeps the case alive.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Extensive Search Found Only A Boat
- Mikita Brottman recounts the massive multi-agency search for Mike Williams that found his boat but not his body.
- Community volunteers, helicopters, cadaver dogs, and a National Geographic underwater camera still turned up nothing for weeks.
Alligator Theory Didn’t Hold Up
- Experts rejected the alligator theory because alligators don't feed in winter and the jacket showed no bite marks.
- Cheryl Williams used that contradiction to doubt the official explanation and keep pushing the case.
A 'Test' Framed As Divine Will
- Mikita Brottman describes Brian and Denise's secret affair and how they rationalized killing Mike as a "test" from God.
- They planned a staged hunting accident to see whether God would "allow" Mike's death.
