The Dishcast with Andrew Sullivan

Charlie Sykes, a seasoned journalist and former conservative talk-show host, explores the complexities of today's political landscape. He shares insights from his contrarian upbringing and how it shaped his views. Sykes discusses the dangers of audience capture and the tribalism in modern discourse. He reflects on the rise of talk radio, the influence of figures like Gingrich and Limbaugh, and how they transformed conservatism. Additionally, he critiques the failures of both parties and the changing dynamics of political argument.

Claire Berlinski, an American novelist and journalist based in Paris, dives into her family's history of fleeing Nazi Germany and her deep love for Margaret Thatcher. They dissect the implications of U.S. policy in Venezuela and the growing isolationism among Americans. Claire candidly reflects on her past errors regarding the Iraq War and shares concerns about Donald Trump's mental fitness affecting foreign policy. The duo also examines the current threats to Europe, NATO's role, and the shifting dynamics of American global engagements.

Laura Field, a writer and political theorist specializing in far-right populism, dives into the complexities of modern ideological battles. She explores the New Right's revival of foundational questions about virtue and meaning, critiquing the emptiness of contemporary liberalism. Their discussion includes the Claremont Institute's legacy and its radical critiques of the administrative state, as well as how economic anxieties have fueled Trumpism. Field also tackles the allure of heroic politics and the controversial figures that intertwined with the January 6 events.

Arthur Brooks, a Harvard professor and expert on happiness, delves into the science of joy and personal fulfillment. He shares how half of our happiness is genetically determined, while also discussing his own struggles with his mother's mental illness. Brooks reveals his journey from a musician to an academic, and highlights the importance of focusing on local connections to maintain emotional balance amid chaos. He encourages embracing creativity and warns against the pitfalls of screen obsession, advocating for a life of integrity over superficial success.

In this engaging discussion, clinical psychologist Simon Rogoff delves into the nuances of narcissism, drawing from over 20 years of experience. He explores the spectrum of narcissistic traits, from healthy self-regard to severe dysfunction, highlighting childhood patterns that breed narcissism, such as emotional neglect and the embrace of achievement over vulnerability. Rogoff also examines famous figures like Churchill and Lennon, revealing how their wounds shaped their complex personalities, while noting how narcissism can both drive ambition and create deep interpersonal issues.

Shadi Hamid, a Washington Post columnist and senior fellow at Georgetown University, dives into the complexities of U.S. foreign policy, discussing the National Security Strategy and America's global leadership. He reflects on his mixed identity and its influence on his worldview. Highlights include a critique of Bush's idealism leading to chaos in Iraq, the consequences of 9/11 on his faith, and the tension between Islam and liberalism. Shadi advocates for promoting democracy in the Middle East while respecting cultural diversity, making a case for a nuanced American power.

George Packer, a journalist and novelist known for works like The Unwinding, shares his insights on modern America. He reflects on his Stanford upbringing and personal losses, revealing how they shaped his political views. Packer discusses the impact of Orwell's clarity in writing and chooses fiction to explore the failures of contemporary politics in his new novel, The Emergency. He critiques societal divides, youth grievances, and the rise of moralism, warning about a collapsing competence in institutions.

Michel Paradis, a seasoned human rights lawyer and historian, explores the complexities of Dwight Eisenhower's life and career. He sheds light on Eisenhower's underestimated leadership during D-Day and his unique relationship with FDR. Paradis shares personal anecdotes about Eisenhower's challenging upbringing and pivotal mentorship under Fox Conner. Discover how Eisenhower's moderation and strategic alliances shaped postwar efforts, and why he stands in stark contrast to modern political figures.

Mark Halperin, a veteran political journalist and author known for his work with ABC News and TIME, shares captivating insights from his career. He reflects on covering Bill Clinton, emphasizing the former president's charisma and capacity to sway opposition. The conversation dives into the insular nature of Washington media, the rise of partisanship influenced by figures like Rush Limbaugh, and the challenges of today's journalistic landscape. Halperin also highlights the potential for restoring civility in media through independent, nonpartisan content.

Fiona Hill, a former U.S. intelligence analyst and expert on geopolitics, shares her insights on Russia's imperial ambitions and the resurgence of populism. She discusses the impacts of industrial decline in northern England and the changing identity of regions. Hill explores how Putin’s miscalculation exacerbated the war in Ukraine while highlighting innovative Ukrainian military strategies. The conversation touches on the complexities of immigration, nationalism, and the international implications of corruption in Ukraine, providing a nuanced view of today’s geopolitical landscape.