Admittedly: College Admissions with Thomas Caleel

In this episode of the Admittedly Podcast, host Thomas Caleel, former Director of MBA Admissions and Financial Aid at UPenn's Wharton School, tackles the topic of safety schools. Thomas explores how the concept of a safety school has evolved—from a carefully chosen handful of applications to a broader strategy in today's Common App era. He dives into the potential pitfalls of this mindset and offers alternative perspectives, including the benefits of community college transfers and the critical importance of genuine interest when applying to any school. Key Takeaways: What Is a Safety School? In short, a safety school is a "fallback school." However, this mindset carries risks—applying to a school you have absolutely no interest in, even if you're accepted, may not be the best strategy. Rethinking Your Fallback Options: Consider that a community college might be a safer bet than transferring from a low-ranked school. In states like California, transferring from a community college can even come with preferred admission status at some top-tier schools. Why Safety Schools Might Reject You: Schools can detect when they're being treated as mere backups. They seek students who will thrive on campus—not just use the institution as a stepping stone to another university. They want applicants who genuinely like their school. When a Safety School Is Your True Choice: If you actually want to attend a school traditionally considered a safety school, demonstrated interest becomes crucial. Genuine outreach and expressed enthusiasm can set you apart and improve your chances. Broader Horizons: Remember to broaden your thinking and consider factors beyond prestige and brand. Explore international opportunities, weigh the return on your investments, and consider your long-term goals to choose a path that sets you up for success. Navigating college admissions is about more than just having a fallback plan—it's about finding the right fit and investing in opportunities that truly resonate with your goals. Embrace the journey, be intentional in your choices, and stay open to all possibilities. Follow us on Instagram and TikTok at @admittedlyco for more insights and updates! Visit www.admittedly.co to learn how Admittedly can help you achieve your dreams.

In this episode of the Admittedly Podcast, host Thomas Caleel takes a moment to reintroduce himself. With so many new listeners joining our community, it's the perfect time to revisit the story behind Admittedly. Thomas shares his journey—from his early career ventures to becoming a leader in the college admissions space—and why he has spent the past 20 years helping students navigate the admissions process with confidence and clarity. Key Takeaways: Where it all Started – Thomas shares his unconventional path, from business ventures in Europe to launching skincare brands in Colorado, and ultimately, how he found his calling in admissions. Why it Matters – A deep commitment to student success has driven Thomas to help applicants achieve incredible things. His mission is to spread valuable, strategic admissions advice to as many students as possible. Becoming a Voice in Admissions – Engaging with other experts in the online admissions space has been an enriching experience, but not every voice in the industry is created equal. What Brings us Here – Success isn't just about strategy; it's about relationships. Building connections, learning from others, and sharing knowledge is vital to Admittedly's growing community. For two decades, Thomas has been dedicated to reducing stress and uncertainty in the admissions process—helping students avoid mistakes, grow productively, and achieve their goals. And this is just the beginning. Follow Admittedly on Instagram and TikTok at @admittedlyco for more insights, and drop us a comment! Visit www.admittedly.co to learn more about how Thomas and the Admittedly team can help you navigate your admissions journey.

In this episode of the Admittedly Podcast, host Thomas Caleel dives deeper into deferrals. He breaks down what deferrals are, why schools do it, and what it means for YOU! Key Takeaways: Deferrals Are NOT Rejections: Understanding what it means to be deferred is critically important to your application process if you're applying Early Action or Early Decision. Yield Management is a Big Factor: Schools act in their best interest, and have ideal yield margins to hit each year. Yield is the number of students who accepted an offer over the number of offers given out and can be a big indicator of how selective schools are. You Can Make a Difference: Letters of continued interest and other supplementary information may be requested from you. This can have a large impact on your chances of being accepted during regular decision. Deferrals Went Up This Year (And Thomas Has Thoughts): Listen in for Thomas' personal theory as on why this year we experienced a spike in deferrals. Being deferred is not ideal, but it does not mean you lost your chance at being accepted. If you have thoughts, want to share your experience, or have questions about this episode, drop a comment on Instagram or TikTok at @admittedlyco. For more expert insight on college admissions, follow Thomas on Instagram and TikTok at @admittedlyco! Visit www.admittedly.co to find out more about what we at Admittedly can do to help you aim for top colleges.

In this episode of the Admittedly Podcast, host Thomas Caleel explores the question, "Why doesn't the Ivy League expand?" As a former Director of MBA Admissions at UPenn's Wharton School, Thomas offers an insider's perspective on the challenges and limitations elite universities face when it comes to growth. Key Takeaways: Ivy League schools aren't responsible for educating everyone – Expanding these colleges would reduce scarcity, ultimately diminishing the exclusivity and prestige they leverage. Most Ivy League schools lack the space to expand – Many Ivies are located in historic cities with physical limitations, making it nearly impossible to significantly increase campus size or enrollment. Building additional campuses is risky – Maintaining Ivy League standards requires top-tier faculty and staff, which can be difficult to recruit and retain, even for existing campuses. While many students and parents wish Ivy League schools would expand, the reality is far more complex. If you have questions, we'd love to hear them! Follow Admittedly on Instagram and TikTok at @admittedlyco for more insights, and drop us a comment! Visit www.admittedly.co to learn more about how Admittedly can help you on your journey to getting admitted into your dream school.

In this episode of the Admittedly Podcast, host Thomas Caleel explores the workings of transferring colleges. He breaks down the process of transferring, why schools do it, why you might care, and answers some questions from listeners! Key Takeaways: You Need to Ask Yourself WHY: Whether it's in your personal statement or individual essays, schools will ask why you want to transfer, and transferring for ranking is not a good reason. Is your current school a bad fit? Have your priorities shifted? Dig deep. How Schools Consider YOU: Schools consider more than your reason for transferring. Your academics, extracurriculars, and recommendations will all have an impact on your chances. Take Your TIME on The Applications: There may be discrepancies in what is listed in the Common Transfer Application and what is listed on the school's page. Always make sure you are comparing the requirements and staying on top of your applications. Local/Community College Transfers: A lot of schools do give preference to local transfers from community colleges – it can be a great option to look into! The transfer process is complex, requiring a lot of time and hard work – Students set on their path to transfer should embrace the journey, trust in their unique story, and aim for the colleges that truly align with who you are. Follow Thomas on Instagram and TikTok at @admittedlyco for more insights and updates! Visit www.admittedly.co to find out more about what we at Admittedly can do to help in your transfer journey.

In this episode of the Admittedly Podcast, host Thomas Caleel answers listener questions from Instagram and TikTok (@admittedlyco) on a range of topics surrounding the college admissions process. He offers advice on balancing academic and extracurricular pressure to avoid burnout, and discusses strategies for applicants not targeting Ivy League schools. Thomas also covers gap years, when to hire a college advisor, international applicants, and how deferred applicants should approach their LOCI. Key Questions: "How do we balance not burning these kids out before they even arrive on campus? Feels like a feedback loop that needs to change. College admissions are expecting more, students are doing more, or doing more elite activities, and then admissions expects these things are the norm." "Would you mind addressing how your intent applies to students that aren't looking at the big Ivies?" "How to balance life as a teen and top academic achievement in a manner that is healthy and avoids burnout?" "Thoughts on a gap year? How do you make the most of a gap year?" "As a parent of a rising ninth grader, when do you recommend hiring a college advisor?" "How important is having national or international awards for top schools? Is having none going to get you rejected?" Advice for international applicants, especially in creating opportunities when extracurricular activities may not be as prevalent in their countries. How deferred applicants are reviewed during regular decision and how to strategically approach a letter of continued interest. Remember, navigating college admissions is all about finding the right balance, staying true to yourself, and focusing on what truly matters. Trust in your unique journey. Be sure to follow Thomas on Instagram and TikTok at @admittedlyco. Feel free to DM your questions or drop them in the comments—there's a lot of great engagement happening between students, parents, and those with experience!

In this episode of the Admittedly Podcast, host Thomas Caleel explores the evolving college admissions landscape, comparing the challenges of today's process with that of previous generations. He offers insights into how applicant expectations, the applicant pool, and the criteria for top schools have changed, and answers some questions from listeners! Key Takeaways: The Shifting Admissions Landscape: While admit rates have decreased, the fundamental traits that colleges value—intellectual curiosity, academic achievement, and community involvement—have remained constant. The Dangers of Over-Scheduling: More isn't always better. Thomas discusses the importance of choosing a few activities that truly matter to you, rather than overloading on extracurriculars for the sake of impressing admissions officers. Quality Over Quantity: Schools prefer applicants who show passion and depth in one or two areas, rather than those who scatter their focus across numerous activities. Parental Support: Parents can play a crucial role by encouraging their children to pursue their true interests and avoid the pressure of "keeping up" with peers. Authenticity in the Application Process: Schools are looking for genuine applicants, not overly-polished versions of what they think admissions officers want. Be true to yourself and let your story shine through. Navigating the college admissions process can be daunting, but it's about finding balance, focusing on what truly matters, and being authentic. Embrace the journey, trust in your unique story, and aim for colleges that truly align with who you are. Follow Thomas on Instagram and TikTok at @admittedlyco for more insights and updates!

In this episode of The Admittedly Podcast, Thomas Caleel addresses the growing pressures high school students feel during the college admissions process. Exploring the sources of this stress—whether self-imposed or external—Thomas emphasizes the importance of intentionality and clarity of purpose. He offers insights into balancing extracurricular activities, maintaining mental health, and avoiding the trap of overloading schedules to "keep up" with others. With a focus on authenticity and depth over breadth, this episode provides actionable advice for students and parents alike. Key Takeaways: The Danger of Comparison: Students often model their activities after peers who gained admission to selective schools, leading to unnecessary pressure and burnout. Quality Over Quantity: Admissions committees value meaningful, sustained engagement in a few areas over a laundry list of shallow commitments. Intentional Engagement: Focus on activities that genuinely align with your interests and passions, rather than attempting to "do it all." Mental Health Matters: Both parents and students need to prioritize balance and well-being. Frazzled and overworked students are not what admissions officers are looking for. Dispel Myths About Admissions: Many stressors stem from misunderstandings or rumors about what colleges expect. Focus on facts and clarity. More is not always better in the college admissions process. By focusing on intentionality, authenticity, and personal well-being, students can present a compelling and balanced profile without overwhelming themselves. For more guidance on navigating this journey, follow Thomas on Instagram and TikTok at @admittedlyco.

In this episode of The Admittedly Podcast, Thomas Caleel delves into the ongoing debate surrounding Ivy League education. He explores the allure, benefits, and potential drawbacks of attending an Ivy or Ivy Plus school. Thomas emphasizes that while these schools can offer transformative opportunities, they are not the singular path to success. He breaks down the reputational effect, alumni networks, financial considerations, and career impact of an Ivy League education while encouraging families to make thoughtful, individualized decisions. Key Takeaways: What is the Ivy League? The Ivy League started as an athletic conference comprising eight schools: Penn, Dartmouth, Princeton, Columbia, Harvard, Yale, Brown, and Cornell. Ivy Plus schools like MIT, Stanford, and UChicago expand the list of prestigious institutions but are not part of the original Ivy League. Benefits of Ivy League Education: Access to world-class professors and intellectually stimulating peers. Deep, powerful alumni networks that can enhance career opportunities and personal connections. A strong reputational effect that can open doors in competitive industries or regions. Financial Considerations: Many Ivy League schools offer generous grants to families earning less than $200,000 annually, but those in higher income brackets may face steep costs. For families in the middle, the decision to take on significant debt for an Ivy degree requires careful evaluation of potential career returns and long-term goals. Regional and Career Fit: Alumni networks often have stronger influence in certain regions (e.g., USC for Southern California vs. Dartmouth for New England). Consider your intended career path—certain degrees (like law or medicine) might make Ivy tuition less justifiable at the undergrad level. Plan Strategically: Ivy League admissions require thoughtful planning and foresight, starting as early as freshman or sophomore year. Understand your goals, strengths, and passions early to align your high school experience with Ivy League expectations. An Ivy League education can be transformational for the right student, offering unique opportunities and networks that last a lifetime. However, it's not the only path to success, and families should weigh financial, career, and personal factors when making this decision. Thoughtful planning and self-awareness are key to determining whether the Ivy League is the right fit. For more tips and guidance, follow Thomas on Instagram and TikTok at @admittedlyco.

In this episode of the Admittedly Podcast, host Thomas Caleel emphasizes the critical role of courage in crafting standout college application essays. Drawing from his experience reviewing thousands of essays, Thomas shares insights into why authentic, bold storytelling is essential for making an impression on admissions officers. He discusses how vulnerability, self-awareness, and owning your unique story can set applicants apart in a sea of polished but impersonal submissions. Key Takeaways: Courage Over Conformity: Avoid mimicking "successful essays" found online. Let your unique voice and personal experiences guide your storytelling. Own Your Story: Don't soft-sell your accomplishments. Showcase your successes and challenges with pride and authenticity, focusing on what drives you. Embrace Vulnerability: Essays should be personal and sometimes uncomfortable to write, as they offer a glimpse into your motivations, character, and growth. Be Fearlessly Honest: Share your lived experiences—even failures—and how they shaped you. This honesty resonates with admissions officers seeking genuine insight into applicants. Not Every School Will Say Yes—And That's Okay: A bold essay might not appeal to every institution, but it will connect with the schools that are the best fit for you. College essays are an opportunity to share your authentic self and connect with schools that align with your story. Be brave, bold, and unafraid to show your vulnerability. Follow Thomas on Instagram and TikTok at @admittedlyco for more thoughts and guidance.