Sed Contra: A Podcast of Catholic Theology

Elliot Polsky, an associate member of SDP and philosophy instructor at St. John Vianney Seminary, dives deep into the intricate meaning of the word 'is.' He discusses medieval theories, including the copulative theory and Avicenna's aspect theory, revealing how this simple verb shapes philosophical thought. The conversation highlights Aquinas's unique perspectives on existence and the profound implications of 'is' in relation to the Eucharist and essence. This fascinating exploration intertwines historical insights with contemporary relevance, making philosophy accessible and engaging.

This lively discussion dives deep into the intricacies of moral theology, exploring the relevance of manuals for modern priests and the evolving challenges in confessional practice. The speakers debate the relationship between universal salvation and salvation's complexities, questioning the existence of hell. They also tackle the nature of divine justice and mercy, emphasizing a thoughtful approach to Eucharistic reverence and the beatific vision. Expect enlightening perspectives on age-old theological dilemmas intertwined with contemporary faith practice!

Fr. Clinton Sensat, a priest and Bonaventure expert from Louisiana, dives into the mystical and theological contributions of St. Bonaventure. He explores Bonaventure's unique perspectives on Trinitarian theology and the Eucharist, contrasting them with Aquinas. The discussion highlights Bonaventure's importance in contemporary theology, his mystical writings, and the debates surrounding transubstantiation. Sensat also emphasizes how Bonaventure's teachings can enrich modern understandings of grace, sacraments, and the beauty in liturgical experiences.

Engaging discussions explore human dignity and the philosophical implications of gender roles, tracing ideas from St. Thomas Aquinas to modern times. The hosts examine equality and complementary roles of men and women through a theological lens, touching on Genesis and partnership dynamics. They critique traditional gender expectations while asserting equal dignity, and address contemporary issues like paternal involvement and church practices. A fascinating blend of modern thought with orthodox theology keeps the conversation relevant and impactful.

Elliot Polsky, a philosophy instructor at St. John Vianney Theological Seminary, and Pater Edmund Waldstein, a lecturer in moral theology and member of the Sacra Doctrina Project, dive deep into the modern shift towards the individual in philosophy and theology. They discuss how contemporary challenges, such as transgender ideology, reshape traditional views on gender within Catholic teachings. The conversation also highlights the historical skepticism towards authority and its implications for faith, urging a thoughtful balance between individuality and community in spirituality.

Dive into intriguing discussions on the Academy Awards as the hosts analyze the peculiar 2024 film slate and predict Oscar nominations. They reflect on ambition versus mediocrity through the lens of modern cultural aspirations. Delve into the morality of usury, exploring historical views from thinkers like Aquinas and the challenges of modern banking. The importance of Latin in theology is also examined, revealing its role in understanding divine matters. It's a captivating blend of film critique and deep theological exploration.

The hosts dive into the intriguing concept of the beatific vision, revealing its theological significance and how it relates to Christ and the Trinity. They explore the perspectives of notable theologians like Augustine and Aquinas on divine understanding. The discussion also touches on the importance of inclusivity in theological discourse and the nuances of private versus public theological discussions. From insights on managing jet lag to reflections on sacred events, the episode blends humor with deep intellectual engagement.

Dive into a lively discussion about the joys and quirks of minivan ownership, from family dynamics to the automotive market's response. The hosts explore beauty as a key characteristic of creation, advocating for its appreciation as a spiritual good. Discover the Italian concept of 'sprezzatura,' celebrating nonchalant elegance. Learn how organization shapes mood in academia, and find tips for navigating the works of St. Thomas Aquinas, emphasizing mentorship in understanding complex thoughts. It's a delightful blend of humor and philosophy!

The discussion dives into the intricate relationship between gender and theology, emphasizing Catholic perspectives. It examines the absence of clear church guidelines on gender transitions, while reflecting on the moral and pastoral complexities. Key insights from St. Thomas Aquinas and Pope Francis are explored. The conversation also addresses the unique contributions of masculinity and femininity, touching on neurological differences and societal dynamics in modern culture, all underlined by the call for compassion and understanding in addressing gender identity.

The hosts humorously navigate winter weather and reflect on the film 'Conclave,' stirring mixed reactions among Catholic viewers. They discuss the balancing act of academic theology with family responsibilities and the struggles faced by PhD students. A critique of modern vocation spirituality emerges, urging a grounded approach. The podcast also explores the intricate link between liturgy and doctrine, stressing its role in shaping community faith. Lastly, it emphasizes how liturgy can transform individuals through its delivery, echoing media theory's influence.