Sed Contra: A Podcast of Catholic Theology

Elliot Polsky, a philosophy instructor at St. John Vianney Theological Seminary, and Pater Edmund Waldstein, a lecturer in moral theology and member of the Sacra Doctrina Project, dive deep into the modern shift towards the individual in philosophy and theology. They discuss how contemporary challenges, such as transgender ideology, reshape traditional views on gender within Catholic teachings. The conversation also highlights the historical skepticism towards authority and its implications for faith, urging a thoughtful balance between individuality and community in spirituality.

The discussion dives into the intricate relationship between gender and theology, emphasizing Catholic perspectives. It examines the absence of clear church guidelines on gender transitions, while reflecting on the moral and pastoral complexities. Key insights from St. Thomas Aquinas and Pope Francis are explored. The conversation also addresses the unique contributions of masculinity and femininity, touching on neurological differences and societal dynamics in modern culture, all underlined by the call for compassion and understanding in addressing gender identity.

Fr. Sebastian Walshe, a Norbertine Canon and philosophy teacher, joins the discussion on the Beatitude of God. He dives into profound insights about God's happiness, contrasting it with human joy and the philosophical teachings of Aristotle and St. Thomas Aquinas. The conversation explores the communal nature of divine joy within the Trinity, the relationship between divine beatitude and creation, and the quest for true happiness in understanding God. Listeners are encouraged to find solace in divine happiness amidst challenges, nurturing a deeper spiritual connection.

Dive into the heated debate on frozen embryo adoption, exploring ethical dilemmas that arise from advancements in IVF. Discover the Catholic Church's perspective on the implications of treating embryos as commodities and the emotional challenges of surrogacy. Unpack the intricate relationship between mother and child during pregnancy, questioning the limits of artificial wombs. The moral complexities of gonad donation and the significance of parental connections make for a thought-provoking discussion, highlighting the intersection of personal choice and ethical obligations.

Rev. Dr. Davison, an expert in astrobiology and Christian doctrine, discusses the fascinating interplay between extraterrestrial life and salvation. He poses thought-provoking questions about whether aliens would need redemption and how this impacts traditional Christian beliefs. The conversation digs into the nature of incarnation and Christ’s dual role, incorporating perspectives from historical theology. Additionally, the exploration of poetry enriches the dialogue, inviting listeners to consider their faith in the context of a broader universe filled with mystery.

Urban Hannon and Joey Belleza delve into the theological concept of transubstantiation, discussing St. Thomas Aquinas' articulation and exploring St. Francis's teachings on Eucharistic piety. They debate the differences between St. Thomas and St. Bonaventure regarding the Eucharist, emphasizing the mystery and miracle of transubstantiation. The podcast also explores the connections between the Eucharist, Blessed Virgin Mary, and St. Thomas Aquinas, highlighting the profound significance of communion and liturgical traditions.

Dr. Mark Spencer, an expert on Hans Urs von Balthasar, discusses Balthasar's integration of aesthetics and theology, interpretation of Christ's descent into hell, and his theological vision focusing on themes like redemption and freedom. The podcast explores personalistic categories, Trinitarian theology, and the enduring impact of theologians from the 20th century.

Exploring the quest to uncover the historical perspective of St. Thomas Aquinas, the impact of Aquinas on theology, evolution of theological study post-World War II, neglected perspectives of the late 19th and early 20th century, transformative power of a book on the Beatitudes, navigating moral uncertainties through historical context, and the influence of Thomism on moral theology and personal transformation.

Listen as the hosts discuss the life and work of Bl. Columba Marmion, OSB, including his background and publications on spirituality. They explore the mysteries of Christ's life, the influence of the French school, the concept of Christ as the ideal priest, the grace of the sacrament of priesthood, the importance of scripture in meditation, and the significance of theosis and divine adoption in the Christian life.

Dr. Kevin Clarke, Dr. Joseph Terry, and Dr. John Solheid discuss Maximus the Confessor and why Catholics should be familiar with his life and work. They explore Maximus's biography and controversies, his canonical status, and his writings on Christ's agony. They also discuss the fallenness of the will and Maximus's teachings on the incarnation and creation.