Sed Contra: A Podcast of Catholic Theology Theology and History II
Sep 1, 2025
Join John O'Neill, an assistant professor at Holy Apostles College, and Elliot Polsky, a philosophy educator at St. John Vianney Theological Seminary, as they dissect the intricate relationship between theology and history. They argue for the relevance of historical events, like Abraham's sacrifice, in understanding divine revelation. The conversation dives into how personal encounters with Jesus shape theological understanding and highlights love's role in enriching knowledge, bridging faith with community ties and profound insights on salvation.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Twitter Poll On History As Theology
- Fr. Ambrose ran a Twitter poll asking if historical botany (e.g., crown of thorns plant) is theology.
- 61.9% of respondents said no, often adding history can inform but isn't itself theology.
Classical Science Vs. Historical Singulars
- Science (per Aristotle/Aquinas) knows causes via necessary, universal principles demonstrated by reason.
- This definition seems to exclude contingent historical singulars unless subordinated to revealed principles.
How Sacred Doctrine Includes Singulars
- Aquinas allows sacred doctrine to be a science because it proceeds from principles revealed by God.
- He says singulars appear in sacred doctrine as moral examples and to establish authority.
