The Commentary Magazine Podcast

Eli Lake, a contributing editor at Commentary and host of Breaking History, dives into the cultural evolution of Christmas music, revealing how popular carols prioritize shared symbols over theology. The discussion explores the role of Jewish songwriters in shaping modern Christmas and critiques the notion of America as a unified white Christian nation, emphasizing historical diversity. Lake also examines the intersection of modern revivalism with political movements and warns of the risks posed by online religion, contrasting it with meaningful communal practices.

Dive into the complexities of the Trump administration's shifting stance on China, AI chips, and economic strategies. The discussion highlights concerns over U.S. technological lag and the perils of exporting core tech to a competitor. Comparisons to past deals underscore fears of being taken advantage of. The episode also critiques political tactics involving tariffs and the implications for voters. Finally, it examines how social media is reshaping local elections and the broader political landscape.

The discussion dives into Pete Hegseth's speech on American defense, dissecting the new national security strategy and its implications. The hosts critique the administration’s failures on immigration, sparked by a revealing New York Times report. They also explore recent military actions against Iran, analyze the strategy's stance on China, and debate the impact of calling back Ronald Reagan's policies. The conversation wraps up with a nod to Quentin Tarantino’s 'Kill Bill,' highlighting its violent yet artistic brilliance.

The discussion dives into the hypocrisy of gerrymandering, where both parties engage in the practice while pointing fingers. Tom Cotton's defense of a controversial boat strike raises eyebrows, while J.D. Vance's 'Golden Noel' remark on a Hanukkah celebration sparks debates about cultural sensitivity. The hosts tackle the tension between politics and entertainment, questioning the sincerity of contemporary leadership. Listener questions about age and cognitive testing in politics add further intrigue to the conversation.

The discussion dives into the media narratives surrounding Pete Hegseth, debating his controversies and Trump's steadfast support. There's a deep dive into the implications of Hegseth's management style and the potential fallout from allegations of misconduct. The panel critiques Trump's pardons, warning of their impact on norms and calling for potential constitutional reforms. Meanwhile, the rise of podcasts shifting audience attention from cable news is highlighted, suggesting a new era of cultural influence in political messaging. Christine also shares a compelling recommendation for Japanese crime fiction.

Jesse Arm, External Affairs Director at the Manhattan Institute, dives into the surprising Tennessee special election results and what they mean for the GOP's future. He reveals insights from his extensive survey of Republican voters, which identifies a divide between core conservatives and newer, progressive entrants. The conversation covers the shifting Republican identity under Trump and the long-term loyalty of these newer voters. They also discuss the tension between achievement-driven and grievance-oriented conservatism shaping the party's path forward.

The hosts dive into the conflicting reports surrounding a military strike on a drug-smuggling boat off Venezuela, debating the implications of media narratives. They analyze the legalities of such operations and the distinction between law enforcement and military action. Discussions then shift to negotiations involving Jared Kushner in Moscow, exploring the lack of clear incentives for Putin. The conversation highlights the geopolitical ramifications of these negotiations and the potential impact on U.S. foreign policy.

Did the U.S. military cross a line with a strike on a Venezuelan drug boat? The hosts delve into President Trump's murky strategy for Venezuela, debating whether it's a new Monroe Doctrine in action. Immigration policy takes the spotlight, focusing on the assimilation of Muslim communities in America. Meanwhile, Netanyahu’s pardon request stirs up heated discussions about judicial reform in Israel and its impact on his wartime leadership. The panel navigates overlapping issues of national security, military actions, and ethical obligations.

Join John Podhoretz, Editor of Commentary magazine and seasoned commentator, as he dives into a range of captivating topics. He discusses the cyclical nature of political debates and the impact of social media on public discourse. John shares insights on Israel's information challenges and examines shifts in immigration perspectives. With a nod to nostalgia, he reflects on his favorite TV shows, like The Odd Couple and The Twilight Zone, showcasing their cultural significance and stimulating storytelling. It's a thought-provoking conversation filled with passion and humor!

Dive into the intriguing world of Trump-era negotiations as hosts dissect a leaked call between Steve Witkoff and Russian officials. They question whether Witkoff was coaching the Russians or just offering flattery tactics. The conversation also highlights troubling terms in potential deals and the impact of U.S. domestic politics on negotiations. Later, the hosts shift gears to analyze Zohran Mamdani's controversial transition team and how it could clash with Governor Hochul, raising questions about policing and political strategies in New York.