The Commentary Magazine Podcast A Bridge Colby Too Far?
24 snips
Dec 8, 2025 The discussion dives into Pete Hegseth's speech on American defense, dissecting the new national security strategy and its implications. The hosts critique the administration’s failures on immigration, sparked by a revealing New York Times report. They also explore recent military actions against Iran, analyze the strategy's stance on China, and debate the impact of calling back Ronald Reagan's policies. The conversation wraps up with a nod to Quentin Tarantino’s 'Kill Bill,' highlighting its violent yet artistic brilliance.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Unexpected Praise For The Strategy
- John Podhoretz was surprised to like the new National Security Strategy despite reservations about its authors.
- He found its articulation of posture and deterrence more persuasive than expected.
Domestic Targeting Undermines Credibility
- Abe Greenwald criticized policy rollouts aimed at domestic political opponents rather than foreign audiences.
- He argued that speaking to internal rivals weakens U.S. credibility abroad and invites foreign meddling.
Hegseth Mirrors Trump's Foreign Instincts
- Seth Mandel saw Hegseth's speech as aligning with President Trump's instincts against nation-building.
- He highlighted strong stances on Iran strikes, the Houthis, Taiwan deterrence, and a Monroe Doctrine reassertion.