The Commentary Magazine Podcast

John Podhoretz, Commentary editor and political commentator, reflects on his father, Norman Podhoretz, exploring themes of intellectual bravery and the importance of steadfast principles. He shares insights into his father's commitment to core curricula in education and the need to engage with challenging ideas to refute them. The conversation also touches on Norman's influence on a new generation of conservatives and the ongoing struggle against extremism on both sides of the political spectrum. The discussion is laced with personal anecdotes that celebrate a profound legacy.

The episode dives into the life and legacy of Norman Podhoretz, reflecting on his influence on neoconservatism and American Jewish thought. It also covers the unsettling developments in the Brown University shooting investigation, highlighting discrepancies in the official narrative. In a separate segment, the hosts analyze a revealing Vanity Fair profile of Susie Wiles, discussing her candid insights into the White House dynamics and the implications of her statements. The conversation wraps up with a heartfelt tribute to Podhoretz's enduring contributions.

Eli Lake, a seasoned journalist and contributing editor known for his critical insights, explores the concept of 'Palestine Firsters' and its implications for U.S.-Israel relations. He argues that this stance undermines American security interests amidst rising tensions. Lake critiques humanitarian narratives that neglect Hamas's role, delves into the historical roots of 'Israel first' accusations, and highlights the strategic benefits of a strong Israel. The conversation also touches on addiction and societal responses, tying in broader themes of policy and responsibility.

Exploring the alarming global spread of antisemitic violence, the discussion centers on the recent attack at Bondi Beach. Panelists debate the implications of labeling such incidents as part of a globalized Intifada. Insights into the failures of law enforcement and mixed responses from authorities provide a sobering backdrop. Accusations of political indifference towards Jewish vulnerabilities emerge, along with calls for decisive action against rising antisemitism. The conversation highlights the complexities of assimilation, immigration, and the urgent need for robust leadership.

Is Trump losing his political grip as 2026 approaches? The hosts dissect his declining momentum and aggressive executive actions. They dive into the implications of expiring ACA subsidies and mixed messaging on the economy. Oliver Sacks's reputation takes a hit as recent revelations expose fabrications in his case studies. The discussion challenges the credibility of literary nonfiction, calling for skepticism toward popular science narratives. Finally, media standards and recent controversies are scrutinized, leaving listeners with thought-provoking insights.

The podcast dives into the U.S. seizure of a Venezuelan oil tanker, exploring its implications for U.S.-Venezuela relations. Discussions include sanctions, geopolitical strategies involving Russia and Iran, and potential consequences of failing to unseat Maduro. The conversation shifts to American electoral politics, highlighting quirky Democratic primaries and candidate dynamics as they prepare for 2026. Amidst the political discourse, a nostalgic film recommendation, 'It's a Wonderful Life,' adds a touch of reflective charm.

Eli Lake, a contributing editor at Commentary and host of Breaking History, dives into the cultural evolution of Christmas music, revealing how popular carols prioritize shared symbols over theology. The discussion explores the role of Jewish songwriters in shaping modern Christmas and critiques the notion of America as a unified white Christian nation, emphasizing historical diversity. Lake also examines the intersection of modern revivalism with political movements and warns of the risks posed by online religion, contrasting it with meaningful communal practices.

Dive into the complexities of the Trump administration's shifting stance on China, AI chips, and economic strategies. The discussion highlights concerns over U.S. technological lag and the perils of exporting core tech to a competitor. Comparisons to past deals underscore fears of being taken advantage of. The episode also critiques political tactics involving tariffs and the implications for voters. Finally, it examines how social media is reshaping local elections and the broader political landscape.

The discussion dives into Pete Hegseth's speech on American defense, dissecting the new national security strategy and its implications. The hosts critique the administration’s failures on immigration, sparked by a revealing New York Times report. They also explore recent military actions against Iran, analyze the strategy's stance on China, and debate the impact of calling back Ronald Reagan's policies. The conversation wraps up with a nod to Quentin Tarantino’s 'Kill Bill,' highlighting its violent yet artistic brilliance.

The discussion dives into the hypocrisy of gerrymandering, where both parties engage in the practice while pointing fingers. Tom Cotton's defense of a controversial boat strike raises eyebrows, while J.D. Vance's 'Golden Noel' remark on a Hanukkah celebration sparks debates about cultural sensitivity. The hosts tackle the tension between politics and entertainment, questioning the sincerity of contemporary leadership. Listener questions about age and cognitive testing in politics add further intrigue to the conversation.