undefined

Robert Mays

Host of The Athletic Football Show and lead episode moderator, guiding discussions on NFL coaching moves, roster building, and interviewing team writers and insiders.

Top 10 podcasts with Robert Mays

Ranked by the Snipd community
undefined
10 snips
Jan 13, 2026 • 36min

Best of The Herd

NFL writer Robert Mays joins to discuss the surprising split between Mike Tomlin and the Steelers after a disappointing playoff exit. He delves into the need for a fresh organizational vision in Pittsburgh and reflects on how Tomlin's departure might impact Aaron Rodgers' future with the team. The conversation expands to potential coaching fits for the Giants and Ravens, as well as the limited offensive candidates this hiring cycle. Mays also speculates on Tomlin's next move—whether he'll take time off or jump into broadcasting.
undefined
8 snips
Sep 20, 2024 • 45min

A Sports Mystery: What Happened to the NFL Quarterback?

In this insightful discussion, Robert Mays, host of 'The Athletic Football Show,' explores the alarming decline in NFL quarterback performance this season. He delves into the impact of smarter defenses and evolving offensive strategies, examining how today's quarterbacks face unprecedented challenges. Mays also highlights the shift from traditional pocket passers to more mobile quarterbacks and questions whether the NFL might revert to a run-heavy approach as teams rethink their strategies. It's a deep dive into the transformation of a crucial position in sports.
undefined
Jul 2, 2025 • 1h 31min

Steeler’s Choice: An AFC North Preview

Join Robert Mays, a seasoned NFL writer and podcaster from The Athletic, as he digs into the competitive AFC North landscape. Mays and Kimes tackle the Steelers’ evolving offense with potential new QB Aaron Rodgers and discuss the Browns’ urgent need for a strong playmaker. They analyze Joe Burrow's continual growth and debate whether the Ravens can finally achieve postseason success. Wrapping up, they rank the division and share their bold predictions for the upcoming season, setting the stage for an exciting football year!
undefined
Oct 14, 2025 • 32min

THE HERD - Hour 3 - Robert Mays from The Athletic stops by The Herd

Robert Mays, a Chicago-based football reporter for The Athletic, shares insights on the rapid turnaround of the Chicago Bears under HC Ben Johnson. He discusses the strategic improvements driving this transformation and dives into the challenges facing Josh Allen and the Bills, emphasizing defensive issues as a major hurdle. Mays also evaluates Bo Nix's fit with Sean Payton and explores the necessity for effective coaching ecosystems for star players to thrive. Lastly, he highlights emerging talents like Drake Maye while critiquing the Jets' coaching weaknesses.
undefined
Sep 19, 2025 • 38min

Best of The Herd

Robert Mays, an NFL writer for The Athletic, joins to share invaluable insights on team and quarterback dynamics. He discusses the concerning state of the Eagles' offense and why Jim Harbaugh's coaching could transform the Chargers. Mays also draws a fascinating comparison between Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott and the Foo Fighters, shedding light on Prescott's unique qualities. The conversation dives deep into the evolving landscape of the NFL, touching on Josh Allen’s impressive growth and the broader implications for team building.
undefined
Aug 22, 2025 • 42min

Best of The Herd

Robert Mays, host of The Athletic Football Show and a keen NFL analyst, joins the conversation to dissect the ongoing contract standoff between Cowboys owner Jerry Jones and star pass rusher Micah Parsons. He provides insights on whether they'll reach an agreement before the regular season. The discussion also tackles the scrutiny faced by Bears quarterback Caleb Williams, with Mays shedding light on his potential for a breakout season despite criticism, emphasizing the complexities of rookie transitions in the NFL.
undefined
Jan 13, 2026 • 34min

THE HERD - Hour 3 - Mike Tomlin Leaves Steelers, Robert Mays Explores What's Next for Tomlin

In a compelling discussion, NFL writer Robert Mays analyzes the surprising split between Mike Tomlin and the Steelers after a tough playoff loss. He highlights the necessity for a cultural reset in Pittsburgh and where Tomlin might land next. Mays dives into the coaching landscape, assessing whether the Steelers should seek an offensive-minded coach. He also touches on the potential impact of Tomlin's departure on Aaron Rodgers' future and speculates on emerging coaching talents like Marcus Freeman in a rapidly evolving NFL.
undefined
Dec 19, 2025 • 40min

THE HERD - Hour 2 - Colin's Blazing 5 picks for week 16, Caleb Williams is making a name for himself, Robert Mays

Robert Mays, a staff writer and podcast host for The Athletic, shares insights on the NFL landscape, highlighting Caleb Williams' rise as a top quarterback with impressive timing and touch on his throws. They discuss the impact of run game on the Rams' offense and evaluate Sam Darnold's mental toughness during his comeback. Mays also analyzes the ceiling for Josh Allen and the Bills while examining the coaching landscape, including the implications for Dallas' playoff ambitions.
undefined
Dec 19, 2025 • 32min

Best of The Herd

In this discussion, Robert Mays, a staff writer for The Athletic specializing in NFL insights, shares his expertise on quarterback evaluation. They delve into Sam Darnold's impressive comeback and mental resilience, contrasting him with the Rams' fourth-quarter struggles. Robert highlights Caleb Williams' evolution as a premier quarterback, focusing on his improved timing and decision-making. The pair also debate the AFC playoff landscape, Josh Allen's unpredictability, and the coaching prowess shaping the 49ers.
undefined
Sep 19, 2025 • 33min

THE HERD - Hour 3 - Robert Mays from The Athletic, Tomorrow's Headlines Today

Robert Mays, NFL writer for The Athletic, delves into the concerns surrounding the Eagles' offense and praises Jim Harbaugh's transformative influence on the Chargers. He discusses Dak Prescott's consistency, likening him to the Foo Fighters. Meanwhile, Jason McIntyre’s 'Tomorrow's Headlines Today' segment offers bold predictions, spotlighting the Rams' matchup woes, a potential upset for Cam Ward at Tennessee, and the Falcons' edge in the run game against Carolina. Get ready for some electrifying NFL insights!

The AI-powered Podcast Player

Save insights by tapping your headphones, chat with episodes, discover the best highlights - and more!
App store bannerPlay store banner
Get the app