The Herd with Colin Cowherd Best of The Herd
Dec 19, 2025
In this discussion, Robert Mays, a staff writer for The Athletic specializing in NFL insights, shares his expertise on quarterback evaluation. They delve into Sam Darnold's impressive comeback and mental resilience, contrasting him with the Rams' fourth-quarter struggles. Robert highlights Caleb Williams' evolution as a premier quarterback, focusing on his improved timing and decision-making. The pair also debate the AFC playoff landscape, Josh Allen's unpredictability, and the coaching prowess shaping the 49ers.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Slinging Sammy's Resilience
- Sam Darnold has won 30 of his last 39 starts across four teams, showing remarkable resilience and late-game production.
- Colin Cowherd highlights Darnold's short memory, competitiveness, and historic 12-win seasons on different teams as proof of his value.
Rams' Talent Versus Special Teams Flaws
- The Rams possess top-tier offensive talent but have recurring special teams and secondary breakdowns costing them games.
- Colin still views the Rams as Super Bowl contenders but flags special teams as a decisive vulnerability.
Rams High-End, Seahawks Fewer Holes
- Colin compares Rams and Seahawks across roster areas, favoring the Rams on high-end talent but noting Seattle's fewer weaknesses.
- He emphasizes the Rams' offensive depth while warning that special teams and secondary holes matter in playoff margins.