The Herd with Colin Cowherd THE HERD - Hour 3 - Robert Mays from The Athletic, Tomorrow's Headlines Today
Sep 19, 2025
Robert Mays, NFL writer for The Athletic, delves into the concerns surrounding the Eagles' offense and praises Jim Harbaugh's transformative influence on the Chargers. He discusses Dak Prescott's consistency, likening him to the Foo Fighters. Meanwhile, Jason McIntyre’s 'Tomorrow's Headlines Today' segment offers bold predictions, spotlighting the Rams' matchup woes, a potential upset for Cam Ward at Tennessee, and the Falcons' edge in the run game against Carolina. Get ready for some electrifying NFL insights!
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Caleb Is A Creation Quarterback
- Caleb Williams fits better as a mobile, improvisational quarterback than a strict timing-and-structure passer.
- Robert Mays sees structural offensive issues and scheme fit as bigger concerns than Caleb's talent.
Wait On J.J. Until Infrastructure Is Healthy
- J.J. McCarthy benefited from favorable college situations that minimized adversity.
- Mays wants to wait for healthier offensive line and run game before judging McCarthy.
Green Bay's Patience Pays Off
- The Packers combine patient front-office building with opportunistic in-season moves.
- That blend and tailored schematics create deep, continually improving rosters.